Purely subjectively, I think low contrast also makes it harder to get annoyed when noticing Someone Is Wrong On The Internet, without also feeling (so strongly) disengaged when I think a low contrast comment has good point.
I actually really like the dimmed blocks of text for highly downvoted content.
But I've made a few comments that were _extremely_ controversial and oscillated wildly a few points up or down over the course of an hour. Once I noticed what was happening, I started refreshing out of curiosity to see how wild the oscillations were.
It seemed like the comment was getting hundreds of votes, but staying around a total point count of 10.
A comment with a point count of 10 and a total of 10 votes signals something very different than a comment with a point count of 10 and a total of 500 votes.
> What does [dead] mean?
> The post was killed by software, user flags, or moderators.
> Dead posts aren't displayed by default, but you can see them all by turning on 'showdead' in your profile.
The hivemind censors any opinion in discord with its own.
Which is one path to harmony and peace. But at what price?
The purpose of this site is to surface content and discussion that is likely to be considered insightful, engaging, interesting, etc. to the specific demographic that reads this site.
Consensus moderation is on point for this. You let the demographic that is on the site determine the value of the content on the site.
Content that appeals to a minority of the demographic here is unlikely to get traction. That's kind of the point, I think.
That doesn't mean minority viewpoints are unlikely to get traction, I do see engaging takes on minority viewpoints get traction on HN, I assume because they are both interesting and fun to engage with for the demographic that hangs out here.
But there's connotations to the term censorship that make it carry a stronger implied moral, or indeed political, judgement than terms like "filter" in contexts like this one.
Maybe that's exactly what you wanted to communicate. However, as phrased, it's more likely to get a knee-jerk downvote rather than a reasoned response.
Which is exactly why I chose to respond, I'd rather see a discussion on the topic rather than either your comment being ignored or removed. After all, that's why I come to HN, it censors in favor of discourse, and though it's imperfect, it does far better in practice than any other site I know of.
Yes, it's a massive labor saver. No, it is not intelligent.
The labor of moderators.