I agree, it's not terribly hard to pick up the basic idea, but it still doesn't lend itself to the idea of being 'self-documenting', which has always been a helpful fallback when dealing with python stuff that I encounter problems with. I guess it kinda just feels like it encourages too shallow of an understanding of what's going on, especially if for some reason I might want to tweak/customize certain things later on; it feels more geared towards giving you a fish, as opposed to teaching you how to fish (which is highlighted by the 'standard' encouragement to use lots of code generation). Even after going through the docs, it took me way too long to get even a vague idea of how to properly set up a custom model/migration without the rails generator tool. But I'll admit, that's all a lot more in the realm of personal preference.
Bundler is cool, but even with strict versioning, setting things up for the first time is no walk in the park. I won't blame rails for that though, that's clearly more of an ecosystem problem. A bigger problem than versioning though (in my eyes anyway), is when plugins follow this 'rails-way' of doing things magically, and leave no clear way to troubleshoot problems when they arise (devise, I'm looking at you).
I too find the rails guides and rails tutorial to be immensely helpful, but it's more because I would literally be completely lost without referring to them every 5mins, than because I find them terribly insightful. I know the django docs aren't really that much better, but since I can usually work my way around a django project without referring them as frequently, I guess my standards for them is lower? Same could be said for a lot of their plugins, because again, at least there I have been able to fall back on 'self-documenting code' most of the time.
I do think rails is pretty cool, and I could see why it got the praise it did, but I would probably only use it on small projects that involved only a handful of people from the get-go, because I would feel bad dropping a newbie onto a mountain of legacy rails code.