Hospitals have no obligation to hire the residents they produce, so an optimal behavior would seem to be training many residents and not hiring them.
Hospitals have no obligation to hire the residents they produce, so an optimal behavior would seem to be training many residents and not hiring them.
The AMA represents doctors, not hospitals, and doctors benefit from scarcity. Hospitals benefit from residency grants, existing doctors do not.
>Do you have evidence of this lobbying?
Here is a source [1]
>Hospitals have no obligation to hire the residents they produce, so an optimal behavior would seem to be training many residents and not hiring them.
Optimal only if they can make money from the residents. Due to the bizarre natures of US medical reimbursement, resident physicians do not bill for their services [2]. While they may provide value in other ways, they are viewed as cost on the balance sheet. This is further complicated by the fact that hospitals dont want to bear this cost if they can get a grant, or simply hire a doctor away from another hospital. Getting rid of the grants would be a step in the right direction.
https://blog.petrieflom.law.harvard.edu/2022/03/15/ama-scope...
https://thesheriffofsodium.com/2022/02/04/how-much-are-resid....
Further, residents, by and large, are paid for by Medicare.
> While they may provide value in other ways, they are viewed as cost on the balance sheet.
Are you saying that replacing residents with physicians would be more advantageous to hospitals? I don't have a sense of the numbers or billing processes involved
This would seem to increase the potential productivity of a hospital. So I am confused by why you say residents are a cost on balance sheets (again, considering that their pay comes from Medicare/Medicaid)
Residents are actually more qualified than many other "mid level" professions aka Medical Providers.
Would I rather see a resident, or a nurse practicioner? The resident of course, because he/she actually completed medical school, whereas an NP may have a nursing oriented (no emphasis on diagnosis) masters or terminal degree.
Here: https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1997/03/09/r...
> Last week a powerful coalition of medical groups, including the American Medical Association and the Association of American Medical Colleges -- the umbrella group for medical schools -- proposed their own plan. Their idea is to limit residency slots financed by Medicare to the number needed for the 17,000 annual graduates of U.S. medical schools.
There's other things like this that folks say "Well, where's the evidence?" and the truth is that the evidence was all around us back then. Now that people have changed their minds on this stuff, it's harder to find as the perpetrators go quiet about it. And you have to search the past which isn't that easy.
I'm sure the pandemic response will be similarly rewritten, especially the business about telling people masks don't work because they wanted to make sure that average people won't take masks that they wanted to keep for healthcare people. That's being rewritten in front of me to say "Oh there's no evidence that masks ever worked and that's why they said that".
Where's the evidence? Well, in many cases, it was everywhere. Truth casts a small shadow on time. The motivated sceptic stands purely in the light.
From the article: "But why should hospitals be interested in this when, under current law, they automatically get sizable government subsidies for training residents who as part of their education take care of many of the hospitals' patients, work long hours and collect meager salaries?"
If this issue were to arise again in today's political climate, I imagine there would be a redistribution of seats away from in-demand specialties to primary care.
https://blog.petrieflom.law.harvard.edu/2022/03/15/ama-scope....