The rest of the thread doesn't show me attempting to win any argument. I suggest rereading that too.
Whichever way my interlocutor responded to my question would neither invalidate his own position, nor 'win' an argument for me.
You are mistaking this form of discussion for a straw man because you are seeing things in black and white, when instead the question was intended to provide context.
Sometimes people ask provocative questions in order to better understand where other people are coming from. Dialog consists of more than just direct argument. Not every exchange is about gaining rhetorical advantage.
If you try playing back the comments in your head as if they are being spoken by a collegial group involved in a discussion, you'll see what I mean.
Your judgement is incorrect because you have misidentified the nature of the conversation. You are imagining there to be an argument where instead there is actually a discussion.
And on this note, do you really think it's helpful to throw comments like "straw man" into conversations you aren't constructively participating in?