From what I see a lot of people have these desires but rarely act on them. People often tell me in confidence when I mention what I do.
I think it's a lot more normative than people think.
It does not have anything to do with magical thinking or beliefs, its years of experience and a deep understanding of the culture and clientele that visits your venue.
Of course you don't have to participate if you don't like it, there are plenty of clubs (in Berlin too) where you just pay entry and thats it.
And thats fine! I do too. But to claim it's impossible just because we are not good at it would be absurd.
It’s really a great example of the narcissistic desire for power and control that drives the behavior of a lot of people in the scene.
And yes, it is possible to quickly assess someones P(an issue) after a career of observing tens of thousands of people and whether or not they were an issue.
These things can both be true.
[And keep in mind a false-positive matters not-one-bit-at-all, whereas a false-negative is (quite literally) an issue.]
We're supposed to believe they're engaged in some sort of vibe curation process to attain the perfect crowd for the night. There's this weird purity aspect to it that is more than a little problematic.
It is the fool that tells the industry-proven expert that they know better.
It's amazing brand strategy but that doesn't mean it actually is the best thing going, of course.
I trust the Berliners I know (and those who have posted here with similar opinions) who don't view it quite so favorably. From them I hear it's a very good club but usually not worth the hassle of the lines and the arbitrary door policy.
This rings true with my own experience as someone who has been to Berghain multiple times over the years - I've never had a bad time, but it's gone downhill, and other Berlin clubs offer equivalent or better experiences without the annoying exclusivity.