If we get serious about producing biochar, we could sequester many gigatons every year of atmospheric carbon in biochar for addition to the soil. There, it would remain stable for thousands of years and improve soil microbiology, increase soil moisture and plant growth, which in turn would provide more feedstock for additional biochar in addition to other valuable things like food.
See also:
A single tree will eventually die, decay, and re-emit carbon. However, it will quickly be replaced by new trees that re-absorb a similar amount of carbon. Despite some amount of carbon exchange every year from growth and decay, the forest as a whole stores a huge amount of carbon as long as it lasts.
Maybe not stable on geological time-scales due to things like disease, disaster, or continental drift; but certainly extremely valuable on the order of millenia.
So you get weird, wrong takes like “because trees eventually die and decompose, a forest stores zero carbon on a net basis.”
But you’re spot on - the new forest will absorb a certain amount of carbon, and then should basically reach a steady state where new growth trees are absorbing a similar amount of carbon as the decomposing trees are releasing (more or less on the short term, but should roughly even out over the medium term).
Of course, there are sometimes things like bushfires, but ideally forest regrown in an area where there was a bushfire re-offsets that (but you can’t claim that against other carbon you release, only against the carbon released by the bushfire!)
One that’s been replaced with clear cutting, which removed the nurse logs the next generation would typically indirectly consume.
by long term I mean a 10k year scale for example (civilization scale), not 100 years (human life scale - mid term), or a few years (short-term)
If we were to reforest those areas that were cut down ("new" forests), that's an extremely effective long term carbon sink.
If the forest now regrow, it's a short term storage (added with the long-term effect, that will take more time to settle, but it's a continuous process, so it's good to have too)
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-019-08636-w
"Soils store climatically significant amounts of carbon (C) as soil organic matter, globally about 2.3 times greater than the C in atmospheric CO2 and 3.5 times greater than the C in all living terrestrial plants1. However, prolonged cultivation accelerates the decomposition of soil organic matter and can cause the loss of 20–67% of the soil C in an agricultural field2,3,4. Between 1850 and 1998, global agricultural cultivation led to the release of ~78 Gt of C from soil as CO2 to the atmosphere4, with ~133 Gt of soil C so released since the beginning of agriculture5. Since the current global annual CO2 emissions from fossil fuels and all other sources are ~10 Gt of C6, soil C sequestration has thus been proposed as a plausible partial climate mitigation strategy that might buy time while low-carbon technologies are being developed and adopted7. Indeed, a recent international initiative has set a target of increasing global soil organic matter by 0.4% per year to help negate some greenhouse gas emissions"
Note: papers about soil use Carbon mass, not CO2 mass, to convert 1kg C ~ 3.67 kg of CO2
And in fact there are situations with root fusion where some roots from one tree get adopted by neighboring trees. You can see this occasionally with stumps that heal over without any trunks at all. I have seen three examples around here and recall the location of two (on a hiking trail less than 200 ft apart).
Not all of the soil carbon from tree roots is in roots. Without the tree, more than just the roots disappear.
But it is possible to make it work faster by crushing olivine and dumping it in shallow ocean.
(this post is satire)