Now, mind you, all of them know that, in order to get the right overall tip, every person can just calculate the tip on what they themselves ordered and pay that -- and it will magically sum to the right value. They might also know that if you had to tip self-consistently -- that is, if you also had to pay a 15% tip on your tip, and a 15% tip on your tip on your tip, and so on, that this process converges and is essentially the same as just paying an effective tip. (They might even be able to tell you that the effective tip is 15%/0.85, if they're still reasonably young.)
Those are the sorts of things they're good at. I know some who will talk your ears off about the convergence of an involution series in a noncommutative algebra and the problems of just finding a nice notation which makes the problem not look ugly, because the idea is really just so simple once you skip past the messy derivation to the intuitive result.
Computing the actual tip? Not so much. Heck, that effective tip? That's 3/17ths, if you really churn the mental gears! Who has time to divide 3 by 17?! That's what I have a calculator for. Except, well, I didn't bring a calculator because we never use them -- but that's what the computer in my office is for.