There is years of green washing to digest before accepting the truth.
From 2010 to 2020 (crisis) Germany burnt less and less fossil fuels for its electricity, and methane (gas) isn't booming (from 90 to 96), while renewables do: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-production-by...
it induced a decrease in its carbon intensity: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/carbon-intensity-electric...
Comparing it to France implies to take every pertinent parameter into account, for example GDP/capita, climate (heating needs) and the fact that France imports more, and exports less (it lost approximately 50% of its industry since 1980) and therefore "avoids" emitting by using products built in other nations: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/share-co2-embedded-in-tra...
What is the end of this work in progress? 1000% overprovisioning of renewables?
Some have taken to calling it "superpower" (terrible name) because by overbuilding to meet the peak demand, you end up with masses of cheap energy at all non-peak times.
So assuming Germany needs 60GW of power you need 240GW of renewables. Thing is, at 15% generation those renewables barely produce the required electricity. Countries don't like barely when it comes to electricity production.
In most nations "providing it when needed" was equivalent to "producing it when needed" because, then, the sole way to realistically store enough electricity (hydro dams) weren't a solution due to inadequate local features (geography).
It isn't true anymore, as we now can store huge amounts of electricity in batteries (mainly in vehicles), as hydrogen...
"Producing it when needed" was equivalent to "generating electricity in a fully controllable manner, using a managed stock of fuel in order to adjust production (especially: bumping it up whenever consumption rises)" because there was no real way to balance things on a large scale by massively benefiting from a remote electricity-generating equipment because transporting electricity over long distances was expensive and impractical (too much line losses).
This isn't true anymore, thanks to (U)HVDC ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_HVDC_projects ), enabling continental-sized grids reducing the effects of wind and solar intermittency ( https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/180592/european-cooperation-... )
Primary energy usage in Germany is split 25% is electricity, 25% is traffic and 50% is heating and cooling.
As proven by the article the whole discussion is a huge red herring.
Amdahl's law applies [0], if I reduce CO2 from electricity production by 50%, my overall reduction is only 12.5%
It is nowhere near the desaster people like to make it seem so.
Also, isn't this thread about Portugal?
As a tought experiment, if all cars in Germany would be EVs, those could store 2 days of electricity usage.
For flat owners solar panel usage increased a lot, but battery production is way behind, the first usable ones arrived this year, but it will take some more years to get out of BETA. Also energy providers in Germany fight this tooth and nails, e.g. there is no easy way to get to the current usage data of your flat to regulate battery usage from solar storage ("zero feed-in").
If you didn't need to, you know, use those cars.
Storage is a huge unsolved problem.
- that Germany has 135 GW combined installed capacity of wind and solar?
- that wind and solar, combined, were only producing 15% of their installed capacity aka 20GW?
- that Germany needed 61 GW of electricity?
- wind and solar, combined, were producing only 30% of Germany's needs?
- that Germany needed to burn 20 GW of coal to cover this?
- that Germany needed to also burn gas, biomass, and import electricity to cover the remaining 20 GW?
This is a misrepresentation.
Solar for example is only ever planned for to achieve about 30% of its "capacity" (due to the whole sun going down at night thing). And even that varies with seasons.
So if you're claiming the German grid planners were expecting the solar to magically 4x overdeliver, and were suddenly let down then that's nonsense.
Onshore wind has a similar number (again, varies by season).
1. 30% is avaerage number which is a useless because at 10 in the morning when I was writing my text solar was even below that.
2. You're literally confirming what I was saying.
> So if you're claiming the German grid planners were expecting the solar to magically 4x overdeliver
I was claiming no such thing. I said, and it is backed by reality, that at 10 o'clock in the morning on a cloudy quiet day 135GW worth of renewables were producing only 20GW.
Which is a fact. I know it's an unpleasant fact, but reality has the unfortunate tendency to be unpleasant.
> Onshore wind has a similar number (again, varies by season).
So, again. What exactly was I misrepresenting? The fact that renewables are overprovisioned in Germany? Or the fact that they were producing significantly less than both their capacity and the needs of the country? Or the fact that Germany had to burn 20GW worth of coal to keep up with the demand?
Or the fact that even if you provision 400% capacity (4x times the demand), and it still produces 15%, you will still need to burn coal through the night.
So it's 18:44 when I'm writing this. Wind is at 12.69% and solar is at 3% capacity. In total 16% of Germany's eletricity demand. It's lower than when I was writing these numbers in the comment when someone called me a liar. 40% of electricity (26 GW) is coming from coal.
Reality has the unfortunate tendency to be unpleasant.
Funnily, but when I keep asking "how much more do we need to overprovision renewables" to meet the demands, I'm met with silence or wishful thinking.