Like, for example, what is this device detecting? https://www.thorlabs.com/newgrouppage9.cfm?objectgroup_id=52...
Like, for example, what is this device detecting? https://www.thorlabs.com/newgrouppage9.cfm?objectgroup_id=52...
As far as special relativity goes, the predictions of Lorentz ether theory and SR are identical. SR is basically a metaphysical theory that discards an absolute reference frame, while Lorentz ether theory keeps it.
I can't tell if you're pranking us, but of course there is. Without thinking too hard about experimental evidence: squeezed states and the Casimir effect both spring to mind. Hell, the photoelectric effect originally led Einstein directly to the quantization of the EM field. Or Compton scattering as another example.
EDIT: for example: https://thiscondensedlife.wordpress.com/2019/08/25/
> The only quantisation needed in the Casimir effect is boundary-induced quantisation, that EM waves should have, right?
No. You need to explain why there is attraction in the absence of EM waves.
fyi the various noise measurements from squeezed states might hold interest for you.
My take after skimming [1] plus references therein, plus those that cited [1]: There is a cottage industry of papers trying to replay the early work on QED. Each paper takes one effect as it was known around 1930 or so, and then explains it using something other than QED.
I find the papers interesting in an academic sense. However, as guidance for how the world works, they build a box around the things they are trying to explain, but ignore the more difficult aspects of experimental data found after the 1930s. For the case of Compton, there are higher order scattering processes which lead to nonlinear Compton scattering, which happened in the 1960s.
To make a specific answer to your comment: My quick read is that Schrodinger's explanation fails at higher intensities, since the semiclassical treatment of E&M will increase only the amplitude of the radiation field, whereas nonlinear Compton scattering will need something in the way of additional terms or mechanisms to explain the experimental results.
More generally, that set of papers seemed to address only the singleton mechanisms but ignored the more general problem of noise and statistics. For example: Increasing the field amplitude in various experiments will reveal the shot-noise profile of photons, but I saw nobody try to approach that problem in my brief survey.
In any case, thanks for the reference. It lead to some interesting reading.
[1] Strnad, J. (1986). The Compton effect-Schrodinger’s treatment. European Journal of Physics, 7(4), 217–221. doi:10.1088/0143-0807/7/4/001
I haven't gone through any of the maths in detail. I do however have a semi-classical electrodynamics computer simulation that I occasionally work on, so why do the maths when you can just run a simulation :)
When I get back to it maybe I will try and simulate Compton scattering or the photoelectric effect.
EDIT: will try and find Compton paper later, going for walk now.
Casimir is not about fluctuations. There is an attraction between metal plates in the absence of electromagnetic radiation.
And as I think it through, an even simpler example is the laser. Bose-Einstein statistics require that you have indistinguishable particles to multiply occupy a state. Without the indistinguishability, you don't end up with the right statistics. Without the right statistics, you don't end up with the right Einstein rate equations, and you'll be missing the stimulated emission term. Without that term, you will be missing the lasing action, as well as secondary effects such as noise statistics.
Nice to see a stand taken on uncommon ground.
Yes, there is: we can make Fock states of the EM field in the laboratory. Such states can only exist if the EM field is quantized.
More generally, phenomena like bunching and antibunching are only possible if the EM field is quantized. Quantization of matter alone is not enough.
Is there a classical explanation of entangled photons experiments?
A theory can be wrong, or approximate, and still be useful for calculations and intuition. For example Newton's gravity theory is wrong (or approximate) but still useful.