I've been through a number of options in the past and this is what I've settled on.
My workflow still takes manual tweaking. When I find floated figures with captions, the lines get intertwingled and need to be unintertwingled. So I'm not surprised it didn't work for you.
Good luck, report back if you find what you're looking for. I'm always on the lookout for a better way.
The other option I have started looking into is the PDFCPU library for Go. It is a bit more low-level than PDFMiner, but one gets out very well structured info, that seem it might be possible to post-process quite well, for one's particular use case and PDF layouts: https://github.com/pdfcpu/pdfcpu
I also now tried the Marker tool in the OT, and it seems to do a reasonable job. It did intermingle some columns though, at least in some tricky cases such as when there were a round shaped image in between the two columns. One note is that Marker doesn't seem to retain styling like italics though.