I'm asking for an explanation that goes beyond "they make money, and I don't understand how, they must be ripping people off!"
e.g. Alice wants to sell at $10.00. Bob wants to buy at $10.05. They could simply trade with each other, but if Eve gets her way, Eve will buy from Alice at $10.00, and then sell to Bob for $10.05, making $0.05 on each share that would otherwise have gone to Alice
What's missing from your explanation is time. If you actually wrote out a specific explanation involving limit orders (like I suggested), you would immediately have seen that.
If Alice wanted to sell at $10.00 and Bob wanted to buy at $10.05, they would have already traded. The millisecond Bob's order hit the market, he would have filled Alice's order (or she would have filled his, depending on which was bigger). Eve never had any ability to participate.
If Eve played any role, there was a time delay. At 12:20, Eve put an order BUY(price=$10.00, quantity=100, time=12:20) onto the market. Alice chose to sell to her at 12:30 because she wanted to trade immediately, with no risk of her order being unfilled. After buying her stocks, Eve turned around and placed a SELL(price=$10.05, quantity=100, time=12:30:01) order. At 12:40, Bob comes along and places an order BUY($10.05, quantity=100, time=12:40), which is filled by Eve's order.
If Alice wanted to hold out for $10.05 she could have. She chose not to, because she didn't want to run the risk of Bob never showing up. Eve didn't "scrape pennies" from Alice and Bob, Alice paid her $0.05 to take the risk of Bob never showing up.