1. Included with the base purchase price you get a predefined period of support.
2. You can pay more to get longer support.
This way users that value longer product lifetime are the ones paying the cost, not the ones who are happy to update to the new version every few years.
Whether or not the specific prices are fair is a different (and much more complex issue). But I think the model makes sense.
[1] Page 13 in https://www.nhtsa.gov/sites/nhtsa.gov/files/documents/mvdefe...
HPE Networking (and Procurve before it) at least used to provide firmware updates to their switches without cost.
Hopefully that's not changed in recent years (no idea).
The question is can Microsoft extend that support for a cost?
Note they did provide a decade of updates.
I think it is reasonable to do this. The alternative is making all users pay for the extended support that only a minority need. I think after a decade it is completely fair that the users who value longer support can pay for it.
If you find a manufacturer defect in a five year old item that has a two year warranty they don't have to fix it. It doesn't matter if it was their fault they don't need to maintain it forever.
Part of the whole "product liability" thing is WHAT IS PROMISED, either in contract or implied.
Most open source clearly disclaims as much as possible, and also doesn't have a clear "party" making claims.
Proprietary, like Microsoft, makes a ton of claims about safety and privacy and doesn't deliver.