> Don’t be fooled. It’s mostly a distraction from what we really need to do right now: phase out fossil fuels and deploy more effective climate solutions.
This is a false dichotomy. I’m yet to find a person that claims these solutions will be enough. It’s just a piece of the puzzle.
> First, industrial carbon capture projects are far too small to matter. > Second, they are far too expensive, costing thousands of dollars for every ton of CO2 removed.
To anyone who treats these kinds of arguments seriously, I highly recommend reading „Why Internet win’t catch on” - a serious article from Newsweek from 1999 ( https://www.newsweek.com/clifford-stoll-why-web-wont-be-nirv... ).
We don’t know if CCS will scale, but we should keep exploring every avenue possible. Especially when we know that certain in certain fields (agriculture, air travel) it will be close to impossible to get to net zero without carbon capture.
Also, if we manage to get the costs of CCS down to €100-200 or so, we can switch from carbon taxation to just requiring companies to be carbon neutral, period. Right now we are in this limbo where we can’t tax carbon polluters as much as it takes to clean up (because the economy would collapse and the poorest people would suffer the most), and we end up charging arbitrary amounts that are not enough to clean up the mess, but we hope are enough to limit the co2 footprint.
Also, replying ad hominem to an article that is ad hominem as well - people who are against CCS are people who are degrowth and just want to get rid of technology altogether. The people that are privileged enough to be able to ignore all the good that technology has brought to developing nationa.