Granted, not always useful if what you want is from major labels, but still, keep in mind that there are options.
Granted, not always useful if what you want is from major labels, but still, keep in mind that there are options.
The second sale was just a couple months ago, and while you can still buy music and download it, it's not true that "nothing has changed" since then. There have been quite a lot of changes, just not on that one front. And it's only been two months, so it's way too early to conclude that Songtradr won't gut it more thoroughly.
Not much changed during the time Epic owned Bandcamp, sure, but that's because Epic only bought it in order to gain standing for their lawsuits with Apple. It didn't fit into their business strategy otherwise, so they had no need to mess with it - they literally just needed it to be a legal subsidiary as a pawn for an unrelated legal battle. The same is not true with Songtradr, which has its own motives and objectives that relate to Bandcamp's actual operations and business.
I agree, the FLAC downloads are a major perk of it, and I'll happily buy music there. But I wouldn't trust it to be around long term at this point. It's too consumer-friendly to exist long term in this modern world we live in. :(
It got sold. Nothing changed. And again, you own the music, if it stops existing that sucks, but only for the future, everything you bought, you still have.
And fwiw, I don't think anything for Bandcamp will change.
Only if you downloaded the mp3s/flacs, and also backed them up.
In the human lifespan terms, our digital stuff is a lot more stupidly temporary than it has any good reason to be, and physical media (especially in the realm of music) has rather outlasted it.
Records (vinyl) from 60 years ago still play perfectly fine with a cleaning, and CDs are holding up quite well too in general. Because my ability to play a record from the 1960s or 1970s is not dependent on the company that created it still being around, and being willing to license it to the company that delivers it for me to play it, at favorable contract terms, etc, etc, etc.
I get paying to support artists and stay on the right side of the law/ethics.
I get downloading a copy of something without paying for a license because it's easier/unavailable to purchase/want to check it out first/it's free!!
But why pay for a bootleg copy?
https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/2412fb/the_web...
https://torrentfreak.com/riaa-and-mpaa-report-notorious-pira...
The gist seems that buying stuff there may be legal if you are Ukrainian or are actually in Ukraine, and quite probably isn't if you are anywhere else.
The RIAA certainly considers them shipless pirates. You are probably paying criminals, and almost certainly are not paying artists.
1: There seem to be a bunch of them, which smells a bit like a coordinated effort.
I just think it might be better to not support sites like that and instead torrent directly for free. No need to sealion.
I'm lost. What do seals have to do with this? Is this a typo, or a turn of phrase I've never seen?
If you want more proof, just look at mp3caprice.com itself. Where is the usual legal stuff like the procedure for reporting claimed infringement? Their single form of contact is a web form. Their privacy policy even lacks a way to contact them.
2. TorrentFreak is hardly a legitimate news source. A simple read of the Wikipedia page on them is pretty embarrassing.
3. Since mp3caprice is obviously not in the USA, they are not bound by our "legal stuff", which can be said of TorrentFreak also.
Expect no more from me. Have a great holiday!
The International Intellectual Property Alliance's 2016 Special report on Ukraine:
https://iipa.org/files/uploads/2017/12/2016SPEC301UKRAINE.pd...
(page 4)
Or their entry on the EU's Counterfeit and Piracy Watch List:
https://web.archive.org/web/20190617061827/http://trade.ec.e...
(page 19)
> According to the music industry Mp3va.com and Mp3caprice.com are popular unlicensed pay per download websites hosted allegedly in Ukraine, which provide mainly music.
> […]
> These sites claim to have a copyright licence for their business from the Ukrainian collecting society called AVTOR, which reportedly has no mandate to represent foreign rightholders.
I'm sure you'll come up with another rationalization, but your money is definitely not going to the artists (unless perhaps you are listening exclusively to Ukranian bands). Just be honest with yourself: you find mp3caprice.com's service convenient and are willing to pay them for it. Just don't pretend that it is the legal route.
If you actually wish to know if they are legal today (rather than just pretend they are), why not ask your national recording industry association? They'll know.