I do think there is a subtlety about the 'wasn't intended to compete with the 6800' line though.
Chuck Peddle recognised the market for a much cheaper version of the 6800 which Motorola refused to make, possibly because they couldn't make it that cheaply with the contact lithography process they were using.
So Peddle went off to MOS Technology (taking lots of Motorola engineers with him including Mensch) to make the cheaper version. To achieve that goal, they had to cut down on some of the 6800's features. Reducing the size of the stack pointer, only one accumulator, and so on.
As it turns out, the end result - the 6501/2 - was actually very competitive with the 6800. So whilst the original intention wasn't to compete with the 6800, in the end it did compete with it very successfully in some important markets.
Of course, in addition MOS Technology didn't have the resources of Motorola and so also couldn't compete with them in terms of support, peripherals and so on.
Note: I wrote the original post on the 6800 that led to the discussion [1] and I'm now deep in the writing of Part 2 of the 6800 story. (So I've now provided spoilers for Part 2!)
Another subtlety: the ecosystem.
Obviously a cheaper cpu encourages usage in more places. Read: more users & more designers working with it.
Over time, that means more tools (including better ones), more OSes to run on it, more application software, more code examples, more existing systems that can be used to kick-start a new design, more knowledge in the field to work around quirks, etc.
Often that ecosystem weighs heavier than cpu features, price or performance. Yeah a 'nicer' cpu will drop in price. But by then it's late to the party.
I guess the flip side was, Motorola had to create all that in-house, and the price of the ecosystem reflected that. MOS dumped cheap chips into the world at just the right time and got hobbyists to do the work for free, sometimes with superior results. Probably no one could've seen that coming in 1975.
In a ~ $1300 computer (Apple II, ca. 1977) how price sensitive was that CPU market to $9?
The 6800 was ~ $175 in 1974 - that does seem like a clear gulf to the other two. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_6800
See also: The Raspberry Pi.
Thanks for a great 6800 writeup, and I look forward to the follow-up! I feel like the 6800 does not get the love it deserves from the current generation of hackers.
Completely agree that the 6800 needs more love. It was a really important design.
PS I'd not seen Mensch's comment that Peddle's intention was to raid Motorola for engineers before - that's an interesting angle!!
Clearly, as evidenced by 6501 drop in pin compatibility followed by Motorola lawsuit settled for $200K and pin configuration change.