This is a testament to why you would want to use AWS virtual instances and never have "a server" - point your domain at a new instance should one machine get ordered off by the FBI.
You think they give a fuck about the other 4 slices on your server? No. They don't. In fact it says so right in their SLA.
If you are trying to defy the FBI, and 100% of your site architecture resides within Amazon's infrastructure you are not robust.
They are all the same == Downtime.
My point is that if you have a "server" that can be seized, you have not designed a robust system.
Imagine the FBI trying to seize Google or Amazon or Facebook (well, a lot easier in the case of facebook only because they have so few datacenters by comparison.)