When I've asked a room full of people "close your eyes. Think of an elephant. What do you see?", 80% of the people say "I see a rough elephant". I've asked "do you really see it? Like, there are proportions, colors, etc.?" Most people say yes.
When I close my eyes and I do this, I see... nothing but dark eyelids with sparkles.
Are the other people I've asked this of lying? Or are you mistaken that normal people don't have a mind's eye which actually reproduces images?
EDIT: OK, I'm curious. I've created an HN poll. Obviously our readership isn't an unbiased sample, but I'm very interested to learn how different people experience this experiment.