I don't think there is a 2nd law of thermodynamics for social and economic processes, and I think that it is provably the case that specific decisions were made by specific people that allowed all of the things you described to happen, and that there are easily conceivable alternative paths we might have taken.
In some sense, IBM is idealistic in the true sense of the word. That ideology is certainly not HackerNews' ideology, but it is more complicated than the simple "capitalist company doing capitalist things" explanation.