Yep, exactly, they had a marginal role.
> This would never happen in north korea or former soviet union
Those are not socialist countries though, just plain old dictatorships. It would also not happen in Pinochet's Chile or Franco's Spain or any other fascist dictatorship supported by the US.
> We all know what communism is, we know what socialism is
My point: I don't think most on HN do.
> I am not sure why you are trying to make up some argument there.
Because socialism is not what the first comment was implying it is. And socialism doesn't mean State capitalism USSR style.
What is the role of the Arab countries in the World's pollution?
Are they not capitalist?
What is the role of the capitalistic countries such as the USA in the World's pollution?
Are they not capitalist too???
The argument presented is a fallacy, not supported by facts and it does not even present the argument correctly.
To be perfectly clear
> you live in a capitalist society not some socialist nightmare. Giving it to the government would be much much much worse.
That whole sentence is one big straw man.
- The opposite of capitalist society is not "some socialist nightmare"
- a capitalist society is not the opposite of a nightmare
- socialist doesn't mean "giving it to the government"
- giving it to the government is not proven to be worse, it is in fact the opposite, we are specifically commenting on "3M knew its chemicals were harmful decades ago, but didn't tell the public". Because the public, the government, is the one in charge of not letting these kinds of things happen. This story is proof against the private sector, not the opposite, which, again, is a "No true Scotsman" at this point.
To be even more clear, no government would kill its people to profit and even if they did, sooner or later the people would overthrown it.
But a private company will without doubt do it, using every trick in the book to cover up their responsibilities, because they do not respond to the people.
We have tons of evidence in support of the thesis.
And that's why we have laws to avoid it and agencies devoted to controlling that nothing like that happens.
Unfortunately they can be powerless against corporations with huge budgets and reach.
> Noan Chomsky lived in academia
This is called ad hominem. Noam Chomsky is a highly respected researcher, you should disprove his works, which are public and available to everyone BTW, if you really believe he's wrong, not attack the person.