Silly specific example in this case, as a healthcare provider, I can't tell a cop you have high blood pressure, because HIPAA. A pharmacy can tell a cop you take lisinopril/HCTZ, which is only prescribed for high blood pressure, because ... shrug.
https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/faq/505/what-doe...
> To comply with a court order or court-ordered warrant, a subpoena or summons issued by a judicial officer, or a grand jury subpoena.
Emphasis mine.
From the article:
> Instead, all the pharmacies hand over such information with nothing more than a subpoena, which can be issued by government agencies and does not require review or approval by a judge.
Emphasis also mine.
Police officers are not considered judicial officers, though they are officers of the court.
"Judicial officers are typically categorized as judges, magistrates, puisne judicial officers such as justices of the peace or officers of courts of limited jurisdiction; and notaries public and commissioners of oaths. The powers of judicial officers vary and are usually limited to a certain jurisdiction."
It seems to me that there's an extrapolation here that is not covered by HIPAA. HIPAA only refers to subpoenas issued by or reviewed by judicial officers, not a blanket allowance.
The provision that pharmacies are using is, I believe, this one:
> To respond to an administrative request, including an administrative subpoena or summons, a civil or an authorized investigative demand, or similar process authorized under law, provided that: the information sought is relevant and material to a legitimate law enforcement inquiry; the request is specific and limited in scope to the extent reasonably practicable in light of the purpose for which the information is sought, and de-identified information could not reasonably be used (45 CFR 164.512(f)(1)(ii)(C)).
> the information sought is relevant and material to a legitimate law enforcement inquiry
Your average PharmTech at CVS isn't assessing the legitimacy of the inquiry or its relevancy, but is instead blindly acquiescing (or being told to do so).
The other part that is a problem is the use of "and":
> and de-identified information
There's no de-identified information in "Show me all the prescriptions you filled for Mr XYZ."
But what there is is enough plausible deniability for the corporations to say they were following their interpretation of the law.
Something like "I'm a police officer with ABC department, and I need to know which drugs Mr. XYZ has purchased between [x] and [y] in regards to a criminal drug trafficking investigation I am investigating" seems to satisfy all of the requirements.
* "administrative request": the officer is asking
* "the information sought is relevant and material to a legitimate law enforcement inquiry": they are real police, and they are investigating a crime regarding this person and these drugs.
* "the request is specific and limited in scope to the extent reasonably practicable in light of the purpose for which the information is sought": It is about Mr XYZ, and it is about drugs he purchased, the crime being investigated is about the same.
* "and de-identified information could not reasonably be used": because it is specifically about Mr XYZ
I think if it's not in the form of a constitutional amendment, then we will be constantly at risk of having it repealed or lessened or made irrelevant by superseding laws.
I understand that we can not go around amending the constitution on a whim, but these topics are so young that we cannot foresee all the possible ramifications of any law that we try to pass but at the same time they are too important to not take action.
A simple, easy-to-understand constitutional mandate such as "no law shall be passed that infringes on a citizens right to digital privacy" would be the ideal solution.
After that, courts can be used to iron out the details and set precedence.
How could congress even begin to keep pace with that rate of change?
They certainly have not been keeping pace, and arguably going backwards in a number of areas (see FISA).
The courts could take every issue, one-by-one, and clarify the reasons for any decisions. These decisions would happen in the light of day with an appeals process ready to handle disagreements about the letter and intent of the laws in question.
> should be addressed by the national legislature in specific and clear text
Congress has not shown an interest in keeping pace with technology, and would therefore be hard-pressed to write such "specific and clear" legislation.
It would, therefore, fall to the lobbyists who have draft legislation ready to go with carve-outs custom made for the companies that sponsor them and which are not in the best interest of the average US citizen.
There is a solution for the problem you're highlighting: Congress passes a law which delegates authority to a regulatory agency. For instance, Congress doesn't need to be an expert on the latest airplanes in order to regulate them. They have assigned the FAA to do this.
Agreed, but I was trying to comment about digital privacy which is a fairly new issue.
> constitutional amendment would allow for a general principle. US laws really do not.
That's pretty much my point. We already have a similar amendment (the fourth amendment) already officially ratified, so this is not unprecedented.
The problem with the fourth amendment is that it was written in a time when the government would need to physically go somewhere and take something, so there is no general principle allotted for digital privacy.
At the same time, there _are_ laws governing ownership of data which made sense when it was the credit reporting agencies trading information for legitimate business purposes, but now we are in a very different landscape of what information can be stored, traded, transmitted, sold at a scale never before seen. These laws would need to be revised and would need the heft of a constitutional amendment to drive that process.
A problem with laws is that there are so many to choose from and they are so narrow. See for example the video rental records law. An extremely narrow law that ignores the broader issue entirely (and which penalty is not even scaled for inflation). Same for credit reporting. Or for HIPAA.
General principle is needed and we are not likely to get that from laws. And in the US that's not what laws are for. Generally. So the 4th amendment could be touched up to correct the fact that it was written when "online", "data", computers did not exist - and metadata was thin enough to not matter too much, and "privacy" was or was not the point and was unclear of a concept. Fixing the 4th would establish the principle that yes, now digital matters and privacy matters and must be included in the 4th. Otherwise we remain in the situation where it's easy to argue that it's not part of the 4th.
Same for "constitution applies only to govt" - where now so many corporations or other groups wield comparable power. There is space for more improvements on the constitution - and then also perhaps now is not a great, constructive time to do that.
The reason other things aren’t in it isn’t because they aren’t or weren’t issues. It’s because they were out of scope for the purpose of that document.