Hacking a game company just so you can show people what is being worked on should not be a crime.
Hacking a game company just so you can show people what is being worked on should not be a crime.
The law is unjust to begin with. I don't blame anyone for breaking it twice. Would I recommend it? No. That doesn't mean I have to judge them for it.
The scary behavior here is his violence; but that violence was clearly a reaction to the violence he was confronted with: being arrested and threatened. I'm not convinced that he is a threat to society.
Sure, I can agree that it was wrong for him to react with violence. But what else could I reasonably expect from someone with Autism being punished for technically-illegal behavior?
Have you ever spent more than 10 minutes with someone who has severe Autism? If you have, then you know not to expect them to be great at following arbitrary rules. That doesn't mean they have to be institutionalized!
The solution to this problem is well-known: treatment. It's clear that that is not the goal in this case.
Plus other hacks in the article.
My criticism is that we aren't talking about fraud: we are talking about hacking. We are talking about legally-enforced secrets.
We are talking about a violent reaction to being prosecuted for hacking. What if was about the fraud instead? Would his reaction be the violent then? We can never know.
I'm supposed to be afraid to live in a society where this person participates. Afraid enough to sacrifice the rest of his life. I'm not convinced.
Let's change the wording around a bit. What makes hacking a "game company" exempt from normal ethics into breaking and entering?
What if the "game company" consists of only a single employee who uses their personal laptop? Totally fine to break into their computer and steal their data right?
Why stop at "game companies"? How about all companies? How about you? Why just computers? Remember that one time when you accidentally left your apartment window open, and then a "hacker" waltzed in and took pictures of all your personnel effects?
So you make a claim, and to try and pass that claim off as believable you change literally every parameter you can possibly change.
GP said:
> Hacking a game company just so you can show people what is being worked on should not be a crime.
They didn’t say anything about hacking someone’s personal laptop to steal someone’s personal data. They didn’t say anything about hacking all companies, they didn’t say anything about themselves being hacked, they didn’t say anything about someone entering their home and stealing their shit.
They said:
> Hacking a game company just so you can show people what is being worked on should not be a crime.
And just to prove you wrong, you can add me to the tally.
Now it’s a view shared by at least two people.
The only exception here is good-faith intrusion testing and the like, but fundamentally: my property, none of your business, misusing my property is a crime.
Beyond that, I don't agree with any of this. If a company wants to keep secrets, then they are welcome to try. Let that be their responsibility.