It might be a bit of a stretch to say it's an open question. This is the first time (AFAIK) anyone has sued over it, so there's no case law. The closest equivalent in "big" cases is probably Lotus v. Borland (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotus_Dev._Corp._v._Borland_Int...).
Basically, Lotus sued Borland because the menu layout of Quatro was identical to 1-2-3. They won initially, but ultimately lost in the Supreme Court. The judgement was that the mechanism for using a program was not a copyrightable form. Prior to this case, I guess everyone sane had assumed that an API was a basically equivalent mechanism (just one for a programmer instead of a user). But Oracle has the constitutional right to sue for what they believe they own, so there's no "short circuit" that would prevent the suit.