Certainly it could be more immersive and give more of a sense of being there, but colorized b&w film is not real, it's guesses (maybe very good guesses).
Certainly it could be more immersive and give more of a sense of being there, but colorized b&w film is not real, it's guesses (maybe very good guesses).
It ain't. It's made up, synthesized in a sophisticated way to become what is normally present in such a context. As such it is by definition fake and not reality, but a sort of consensus opinion of what usually goes into any given spot.
You are not even approaching reality. You're approaching what is typically expected, synthesized to most plausibly fill in the gap. If there is some unusual detail in the original media, the restoration will read it as damage or a glitch, and will wrest it from you and force it into a more predictable form.
I know that colorized film sometimes picks the wrong colors, but really, so what? It's still way better and more watchable than b&w.
What does that mean? Then color pictures are not real either because the world is not limited by 10 bits of color. Makes no sense.
> It's still way better and more watchable than b&w.
Well, we can agree to disagree on this; clearly I'm in the minority that wants to watch films as originally captured/presented. But I wouldn't object to someone saying the altered versions are more watchable --- more people are willing to watch them; and better I wouldn't object vigorously too. I'm objecting to it being called real and true. The original images, limited as they are are more real than an intepreted image based on the actual image. Just as actual images are more real than a reenactment, even though a reenactment allows for much nicer image capture that could be more immersive and better.