Source: a link you posted to HN in 2020 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22223177)
> Of course the IRA exists, but its influence is totally irrelevant
Source: you
> Moreover, the whole "foreign disinformation" narrative is simply being used to lay the groundwork for the idea that people cannot self-govern.
Source: you
Is it surprising that someone interested enough to post in this thread would have had a past interest in the subject as well? It's hard for me to understand how this is a good-faith, thoughtful response. There have been many other takedowns and a lot of other reporting as well, but the link provides some decent insight with a level of detail that an HN reader would appreciate. The tl;dr: most of the "Russian bots" research was, as I summarized, bunk, and pushed by people such as Bill Kristol and other establishment people behind prior false propaganda. I am not sure what "look, you posted this before" is supposed to mean.
> Source: you
Here is an article published in Nature.
Finally, we find no evidence of a meaningful relationship between exposure to the Russian [specifically the IRA] foreign influence campaign and changes in attitudes, polarization, or voting behavior.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-35576-9
> Source: you
Sure, but you can find op-eds and comments everywhere opining that the "new" nature of disinformation and misinformation on the Internet requires corporate-state collusion to censor and repress, lest those people who are susceptible to these campaigns (never, of course, the experts or the people in government) vote the wrong way.
Although I am reluctant to even mention it due to its politicization, the Hunter laptop story is a fine example; claiming the story was Russian disinformation with a total lack of evidence (a claim that persists in some quarters to this day!) damaged the credibility of news institutions and intelligence agencies more than any actual Russian disinformation. The fact the actual story was largely a nothingburger makes it even worse. It gives the appearance that people in positions of influence and power attempted to repress a story that did nothing more than paint someone related to the President in a bad light. Indeed, it's incredible and shameful that the NYT took years to print stories like this [1] which could have been used to refute people quoting the "don’t worry unlike Pop I won’t make you give me half your salary" text because they preferred to leave responsible people with the impression that it was all total fiction and Russian disinformation. Rather than trusting the electorate, the NYT, Twitter, and government intelligence agencies believed it was better to mislead them rather than risk them voting incorrectly. In other words, people are not capable of self-government.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/22/us/politics/hunter-biden-...
That link is merely disputing the argument that bots were involved in disinformation campaigns. This is irrelevant in the discussion that such campaigns were conducted, which you agree with yourself, and the fact that they're wildly successful.
We know this because of their use in influencing elections in dozens of countries by companies like Cambridge Analytica. They certainly weren't the first nor will be the last, just the ones that got the most exposure.
We also know that social media is filled with bot accounts that spread disinformation. This also isn't new, and you don't need to be a researcher to verify it.
We also know that Russia and China don't have the military capability to fight the US, but they certainly have a technological one to conduct these operations. This war is not new, as you say, but with the advent of the internet it has become the most efficient and effective way to destabilize a nation.
So, by the powers of deduction, and without using any biased sources, we can conclude that a) information warfare exists and the US and its enemies are taking part in it, b) a US election would be a major event prime for attack, and c) it would be trivial to deploy bots to run these operations.
Reaching any alternative conclusion would be delusional, and evidence that counter propaganda does indeed also work.
I absolutely dispute the fact they were "wildly successful." People want to make this claim because it conveniently makes their political opposition ignorant tools befuddled by foreign powers rather than legitimate dissent. One might argue that nothing is more "destabilizing" than the polarizing idea your domestic opposition is brainwashed by foreign enemies.
>? We also know that social media is filled with bot accounts that spread disinformation. This also isn't new, and you don't need to be a researcher to verify it.
Except we keep finding the alleged bots aren't bots at all. My own Twitter account was, according to these groups, a bot. Perhaps we don't really "know" that at all. Perhaps most actual bot accounts have close to zero engagement.
> This war is not new, as you say, but with the advent of the internet it has become the most efficient and effective way to destabilize a nation.
No amount of Facebook ads can destabilize a nation, and nothing out of the Internet-era has come even close to the impact of past influence campaigns, although no doubt as t -> infinity, we'll see something.
You're disputing this based on... what exactly?
The effectiveness of propaganda is widely studied and known, so it's unsurpising that an industry that applies it using modern tools would be very profitable. Companies like Cambridge Analytica have been successful all around the world for decades now. See https://www.propagandamachine.tech/ca-map
How instrumental their impact was in achieving a specific result in elections is debatable, simply because the effects of propaganda are difficult to quantify by definition. But it's ignorant to claim that this impact is negligible, or that the current sociopolitical climate can be explained by "legitimate dissent".
> No amount of Facebook ads can destabilize a nation, and nothing out of the Internet-era has come even close to the impact of past influence campaigns
How do you reach this conclusion? The internet is the greatest propaganda delivery method the world has ever seen, and we've known the effects of propaganda for a long time. It doesn't take a genius to put two and two together, yet you're actively claiming otherwise without a shred of proof.
But people have tried.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-35576-9
> Finally, we find no evidence of a meaningful relationship between exposure to the Russian foreign influence campaign and changes in attitudes, polarization, or voting behavior
> It doesn't take a genius to put two and two together, yet you're actively claiming otherwise without a shred of proof.
The burden of proof is on people claiming that foreign countries doing the same thing they've always done with a new delivery mechanism has changed anything. And given the amount of bad faith disinformation already put out by the primary actors insisting this is the case - not people in comment threads, I mean organizations like New Knowledge and other sources used by NYT and USGov - the burden of proof is pretty high. If you have to blatantly make stuff up, your credibility goes down.
> that the current sociopolitical climate can be explained by "legitimate dissent".
Why?
This seems like a very puzzling statement when considering the past century. Aside from the impacts of increasing atomization and social disintegration related to population churn and mass media (not news, but movies, TV, Instagram, etc.), the only really unusual thing about today's socio-political environment is the degree to which dissent is not tolerated and treated as fundamentally subversive. And even that's not too unusual; for example, the pacifists and isolationists today are Russian bots, the pacifists and isolationists of yesteryear were Nazi apologists, secret communists, etc.