It's my account that's at risk of hijacking, so I should be able to decide. If I opted for no 2FA despite Google begging me to turn it on every login, that's my decision.
And the answer should never be just "sorry, we can't confirm your identity right now". If I pass every challenge Google throws at me, I should be let into the account, period. If they have more, sure, whatever, let's play the game, but if I did everything right and still can't get in, that's a broken authentication system.