The main problem with Nu is that it can't really be used as a full-time shell because it doesn't support job control, so a lot of nodejs-based CLIs I need for my job seem to lock up the shell. I got around it by using pueue (a daemon that manages processes), but it's clunky to say the least.
I do think it'll get better as it matures, but I've been through all that pain with Fish and I'm not sure I want to put myself through that again.
[0]: https://github.com/LukeChannings/dotfiles/blob/148a5021da464...
Fish:
- customizing or debugging Fish's completion was utter torture; the defaults are horrible like "carTAB" completes to "blkdiscard" when I don't have cargo in PATH
- nothing in Fish seems to have a useful `--help`, no useful summaries & quick refreshers, just punt the user to a big verbose man page
Nushell:
- no job control, no background jobs
- error handling is utterly broken
- control-C breaks unexpected things, what gets aborted seems up to luck (e.g. aborts the prompt building)
- globs inside quotes, `ls "*"`
- lots of weird parsing errors & bad edge case behavior
Hard to compete with such a mature offering.