That said, it's also range extended so 50kWh is ample. I would hazard a guess it would do about 100 miles on battery alone.
That said, it's also range extended so 50kWh is ample. I would hazard a guess it would do about 100 miles on battery alone.
Tbh that's an awful combined range and it shows how heavy and inefficient the car is. My Volvo XC60 PHEV only has about 50km EV-only range, but combined with its 75 litre tank it can easily do 1000km, no problem.
Which "same range"? Did you just calculate electric efficiency using the total range including gasoline? In that case your PHEV needs an infinite times the electricity of a car driving on gasoline alone.
If anything on paper the U8 is 10% more efficient (Volvo says 50km from the 15kWh battery, not 10kWh). With gasoline factored in you have two vehicles with equal 1000km range despite the U8 being significantly heavier.
You can argue that the CLTC isn't nearly as accurate as the WLTP and you'd be right but you still need to check your math and/or logic above.
Volvo can do 1000km using 75 litres of petrol + 10kWh of electricity(and it is 10kWh in my model, 15kWh is a newer one).
BYD can do 1000km using 75 litres of petrol + 50kWh of electricity.
The math on this is very simple, no?
So, with regular gas:
75L + 50kWh: 75 * 0.815 + 50 * 0.162 = 69.225
75L + 10kWh: 75 * 0.815 + 10 * 0.162 = 63.525
A difference of 10.3%.With premium gas:
75L + 50kWh: 75 * 1.026 + 50 * 0.162 = 85.050
75L + 10kWh: 75 * 1.026 + 10 * 0.162 = 78.570
A difference of 8.2%.You failed to mention it's the gas part that's frigging expensive.
You mix and match units when calculating a ratio of efficiency and it gets you meaningless conclusions. By your "logic" a Tesla M3, a leader in electric efficiency, is the worst of the bunch. It needs ~100kWh of electricity to drive the same 1000km distance. And ICE cars can do that trip with 0 electricity, many even with less fuel so they must be the best?
It makes no sense other than for you to feel good about your car. But your car needs 10-11kWh to drive ideally a pathetic 30km (!) and 75l of fuel for the other 970km. Other ICE cars, or non-PHEV XC60 (the diesel) need no electricity and 50-60l of fuel for the same distance. And they're much cheaper to buy. So why did you pay anywhere between 15k-45k EUR more to have a "compliance car" hybrid that doesn't even float (/s) when this means you're just getting "less efficient"? Unless you bought the bragging rights, and now you're here to defend them.
The goal of any electrified car is to drive as much as possible on electric power alone without the need to run the engine. Not only because ideally some owners can make their own electricity but also for comfort and emissions.
Car A: needs 75 litres + 10kWh of electricity to cover 1000km
Car B: needs 75 litres + 50kWh of electricity to cover 1000km.
Even a child could point out which car is more efficient, as it needs less energy to travel the same distance. Am I wrong about this? If yes, please tell me how, I'm genuinely listening.
>>It makes no sense other than for you to feel good about your car.
I was trying to make a point that another large and mostly pointless SUV can do the same distance, using the same amount of fuel, and LESS electricity. That's literally all. I could also point out how either of those cars is idiotic, because as you said, a diesel version of the same car will use less fuel and no electricity. I used my own car as an example of a car that is also a "bad" example of efficiency.
I apologize if that wasn't obvious, but man, you really got hung up on this.
>>So why did you pay anywhere between 15k-45k EUR more to have a "compliance car" hybrid
In case you are genuinely interested and not just trolling - because in my use case I'm within the EV only range nearly every day, and my long term petrol usage average over 50kkm is 2.1L/100km.
>>But your car needs 10-11kWh to drive ideally a pathetic 30km (!)
It doesn't, but I don't see any point in explaining to you how my own car works, nor was it a point of my entire comment.
> in my use case I'm within the EV only range nearly every day
Aha! Progress! EV only range didn't matter to you until just now despite my mentions, probably because your car has a meager 30km peak range while the U8 can do ~200km. So the U8 is for people who want an EV that's good for any daily commute (even with A/C or heating), with the engine for road or off-road trips. I guarantee you nobody sees these 2 cars competing in any segment.
> It doesn't, but I don't see any point in explaining to you how my own car works
Luckily you don't need to, we live in the information age. You said 10kWh battery, Volvo says it's good for ~30km in ideal conditions.
My friend, your car was the peak of compliance cars, built only to fetch the EV subsidy, with the tiniest of batteries in that segment, and less EV range than you're implying. You insist on combining it with the tank of gas so it looks marginally more efficient than the Chinese luxury tank. But almost nobody cares about that combo. People care about EV range or gas economy. Your car is a bad at both, with the comically short EV range and an inefficient gas engine pulling 2.5t. Why bother trying to make it look better by some skewed metric nobody cares about?
In addition, if we compare only the first 180km, your Volvo (using regular gas) comes out at
75 * 0.815 / (1000 - 50) * (180 - 50) + 10 * 0.162 = 9.98
which is actually more expensive.Edit: All the precise calculations are in fact quite pointless.
> so the owner is definitely going to notice it on their energy bill.
Highly doubt owners of $150k SUVs are sensitive to ~$600 more over 100k kilometers.
The BYD can do 180km on a 50kWh battery, that’s 28kWh per 100km.
How did you arrive at 5x worse? It’s not even 2x worse. And again, I don’t buy the 50km claim from Volvo, outside of perfect conditions (eg daytime in May, no rain, no AC, low air resistance).
>>How did you arrive at 5x worse
You have two cars, they both are fully charged and fueled up. They both drive 1000km and then stop. They both burnt 75 litres of petrol, but one used 10kWh of electricity, the other used 50kWh of electricity.
How much more electricity has the second car used Vs the first one?
On shorter trips, the BYD will come out on top because it can go on battery for way longer, which is (even at 27kWh/100km) cheaper than the Volvo on gasoline/Diesel.
The charging functionality is just a bonus for hybrids (I doubt many people drive a big part of their mileage electric by plugging in). Primarily, the battery serves to conserve energy while decelerating. The BYD obviously also uses the battery as a buffer for its range extender, but the Volvo doesn’t do that.
No, I'm literally going off what the manufacturer said - 1000km range when the battery charge and fuel tank are combined. That's it.
People keep making comparisons for shorter trips, for driving with an empty battery, for driving on battery range only etc etc etc - all of it misses the point I'm making.
>>I doubt many people drive a big part of their mileage electric by plugging in).
If they don't, then why buy a PHEV at all? If you have a PHEV and never plug it in, then your efficiency will be worse than that of a simple MHEV or even a straight up ICE-only car.
We can’t compare the full 1k to 1k km yet because EPA ratings aren’t out - the BYD might as well make 100km more than the Volvo with 75L.
> If they don't, then why buy a PHEV at all?
Subsidies + CO2 ratings (important for EU).
PHEV is a green washing ploy IMO. Plugging in every day is hard enough as it is, I’ve had a fully electric Ioniq for 3 years. I don’t believe many people will do that for just 36 miles (20 in winter), every day. A big chunk of owners don’t even have the infrastructure to charge daily. With an EV you are also often forced to look for destination charging, but with an PHEV it’s perfectly fine to skip that - and people do.
True
>>PHEV is a green washing ploy IMO. Plugging in every day is hard enough as it is
So I disagree in the sense that they do work absolutely amazing if your usecase works for what they offer. Our Volvo does 20-30 miles in EV mode, but that covers my driving needs every day, and we have a charging point outside of the house, so plugging it in every day is literally not a problem. In consequence this car just doesn't use any fuel - I drive it every day but fill it up maybe once every 3 months. In fact the main argument for buying it was how much it was going to save us every month on fuel compared to our last car - which turned out true, the savings more than offset the larger finance cost of buying it.
But on the other hand, I know someone who owns one living in an apartment in a big city, without any good way to charge it - in that case it's an idiotic thing to own, he's basically lugging around 400kg battery pack, ruining his economy, for no reason at all.
>>but with an PHEV it’s perfectly fine to skip that - and people do.
Maybe some do - I wouldn't stop at a hotel without charging point, because even though the range is only 20-30 miles in EV mode it makes a really big impact on overal economy.