You’re extending concepts from one part of finance to another without context. Leveraged buyouts, the OG behemoth of PE, are not necessarily based on unlimited growth or profits. They’re one of the few models where steady-state (or even declining) profits sing.
(Not arguing for PE ownership of hospitals, by the way. I think they should be cooperatives.)
Now someone does a leveraged buyout. The business has to pay 10m a year to service the debt. Now it's suddenly losing 500k a year. If things continue they might have to shut down. Think of poor Joe, his wife just had a child. Could he find another good job in this economy? But... if we bend the rules just a tiny bit, we could turn that loss into a profit... It's for the greater good, isn't it?
This is orthogonal to leveraged buyouts or even capitalism; it’s maximising personal gains without thought to broader effects.
> But... if we bend the rules just a tiny bit, we could turn that loss into a profit... It's for the greater good, isn't it?
This is a fairer critique. LBOs impose pressure. But this also happens in any other constrained environment. It’s difficult to say why that leads some people to innovate and become disciplined and others to cut corners.
The difference between an LBO and unlevered buyout is the financing. That, in turn, means who can finance it. Arguing leverage causes moral decay is, at its core, an argument that ownership of these businesses should be constrained to the already wealthy; it’s aristocratic morality.
Grounding my scepticism of your claims is that most LBOs create value. They create employment. And for many businesses with low or no growth prospects, they’re the only way for them to persist. That said, they’re daring and glamorous and that means they get written and talked about more than e.g. municipal bonds.
https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2018/04/11/goldman-asks-is-curing-p...
PE owning healthcare is especially problematic because nickel and diming on healthcare is playing with actual lives.
A well-run healthcare system keeps people out of the healthcare system. Eg. every $1 spent in preventive care avoids $10 (not actual numbers) in other costs down the road through surgeries and other services.
Translate into capitalist terms, our fee-for-service model heavily incentivizes increasing profits through poor patient outcomes.