I went to university starting 2004 for an electrical engineering degree, and our programming classes were basically structured around OO Java as a panacea.
Later in life, listening to the Berkeley SICP lectures made me realize what a joke the whole thing was.
I don't think Java OO zealots are a straw man. I think they're very common, and many of us are living in a happy Hacker News and startup bubble, where people we meet are surprisingly competent.