I think the products are optimized for the tests, not long-term ownership. Rigors of ownership are what you see reflected in the comments.
Like Bose QC45s. Feel nice. Sound great. Works well overall, for the first year. Then the firmware started acting up, mic stops working during Zoom calls, and getting secondary pairing to work correctly makes breeding pandas look easy.
I will refer to Consumer Reports once I start shitting golf balls.
Otherwise they're a decent place to maybe start but they're definitely not the be all-end-all.
What I do is search until I find a forum of people who obsess over whatever it is. Here's my plumbing one: https://www.terrylove.com/crtoilet.htm
Rtings is expanding pretty rapidly to things not screens, and they bring a much more scientific and modern approach to consumer device testing.