Agreed. Torts require damages.
Agreed. Torts require damages.
Not to get too in the weeds, but breaches of implied warranties were once/began as torts.
But, yes, I guess I was a little glib. I should have said -- it would be sensible to require damages for these types of actions.
Although I'm not sure I agree with the author's formulation:
> HOWEVER, liability would only be established if a weakness is actually exploited, to help avoid the problem of people proactively scanning for weaknesses and then troll-suing as a way to make money.
I think we should encourage customers to look for vulnerabilities. Damages analyses can take into account depreciation, reasonableness of damages/troll suing, etc. If you have 100s of devices you must replace because the vendor won't patch, and your patch request is reasonable (high consequence vulnerability) within 5 years of purchase, I think damages accounting for depreciation make sense, without proof of exploitation.
EDIT: Implied 2nd quoted portion was the parent commenter's notion when it was a summary of the author's position.
I suppose you can construct a regime in which feds come in a fine you simply for having an insecure device, but a lighter touch approach is to wait for damages, which given this scenario, perhaps never comes.
They should pay to replace the functionality, and some punitive fine, as a start. Then we can get into whatever damage their negligently designed device did (did it participate in a DDOS? Did it attack other devices on your network?)
Ahh.
Simply having to replace a defective device would be "damages". The only Q would be: Was it reasonable to replace given the threat?
Nope, the recall usually just means you bring it to a mechanic and they get a replacement part that does basically the same thing, but hopefully correctly this time.
Fixes like yours… hey, if it works it works, right? But the device is not exactly what was sold, if it had an Ethernet port and presumably some corresponding network functionality, there’s some value they ought to owe you for. Maybe the fix could be to ship out locked down raspberry pi to sit between the device and the rest of the network, haha.