I can highly recommend Ente Photos[0]. It has automatic backup, and a very good replication architecture for maximum reliability[1]. It's also super easy to use and everything is encrypted by default.
Aside from obvious privacy advantages, is the software better than/on par with Google Photos? Their object detection is top-notch(I guess that's what you get when there's literally whole internet worth of data we give them) and it's one of the major things that my partner uses it. I don't think she'll be happy with lesser one for effectively double the price...
The app definitely has a great UI and usability. It also has ML-based search[0]. Not sure how both compare exactly to Google Photos since it's a very long time since I've used that, but I'd say it's probably at least on par.