As a thought experiment, it's pretty good. But there's no real practical application.
As a thought experiment, it's pretty good. But there's no real practical application.
If such a shield becomes operational, then there's no reason not to first strike anyone without such a shield, as there'd be no repercussions.
So, by that same logic, the opponent knows this, and thus, it's in their interest to first strike, before the shield becomes operational. So the MAD doctrine no longer applies, and we'd have destroyed the world.
Therefore, even starting to make such a technology will very quickly spiral the world into a nuclear appocalypse.
An ABM system can be developed surreptitiously; it wouldn't be easy to distinguish ordinary research launches from ABM test launches, or to distinguish ABMs from other kinds of air-defense missile. Patriots, for example, are supposedly able to defend against ballistic missiles.
If you can't detect another state developing ABM systems, then the treaty becomes unenforceable, and is a destabilising factor.
People don't sign treaties that prevent them from doing whatever it is they want to do. It follows that the parties didn't want to develop/overcome ABM systems. When one of the parties changed their mind (under Ronald Ray-guns), the treaty ended.
But it turned out to be very difficult and expensive to build an ABM system that can protect much more than an airbase from ballistic missiles. Protecting something like the entire continental USA was infeasible.