The industry was slowly self correcting. People were free to do what they want (what a nasty word "free"). And some people used paper, other plastic. Then the government started to "help". First they banned paper because "the trees" of course, leaving plastic only, then they "banned" the plastic. Which of course was never a ban, yet a tax that just really nailed the poor more than anyone else. (NICE BONUS!!).
So now you would pay .10 a bag. And who knows where that massive amount of money went! Another government compelled transfer of wealth from the poorest to the richest! (SUPER BONUS!!). And what did the environment get for all this devious underhanded corrupt dealing? Surely at least the goal was met! NO! Old mother nature got THICKER bags that likely will outlast the heat death of the universe (MEGA SUPER BONUS!).
OH but people were supposed to _bring_ bags, don't you see! It was the nasty "free" people at the end of the day that mucked it all up again! But it turns out reusing bags is really bad for your health! You would have to clean and disinfect the bags every time to prevent the spread of harmful mold, bacteria, and whatnot. Which in turn is far more wasteful and harmful to the environment than the reusable thin plastic.
So it seems the ultra thin fast decomposing bags were likely the best bet. Good luck reprogramming the public to buy that! But no no no, why stop a dumpster fire when you got it good and going, we're going to have YET ANOTHER GOVERNMENT LAW TO FIX THE FIRST TWO (three? Was it three?) GOVERNMENT LAWS!
This time they got it! This time for sure it's all going to go well.... or, perhaps, let's make a prediction now. We moved from 8lbs per year per person to 11lbs in just under 20 years thanks to these laws. Here's a prediction: this is not a logarithmic curve, this one's exponential baby! We're going to take it up to 20lbs/person in the next decade! Let's do this!