As a teacher my grandfather had a special fondness for teaching handwriting. He read literature on it and conducted his own experiments using his pupils, trying to figure out what worked and what didn't.
One of the things I recall vividly is him explaining to me as I started school, how it was vastly beneficial to use thick pencils when first learning to write by hand. He gave me, as he gave his students, a pencil he preferred which as I recall had a diameter about 1.5x a regular pencil. It was also slightly softer, around 2B.
As I recall his explanation was that the larger pencil required less motor skill precision, which lead to more relaxed fingers hence reduced strain. The softer graphite also required less pressure, again reducing strain.
As I recall he had found the reduction in strain really helped kids get comfortable with writing by hand.
I feel like since I've mostly been typing things for the last 30 years that my motor control for hand writing isn't all that good anymore either. When I do write by hand it's less legible than it was when I was in my 20s (now in my 60s).
for me that's the point of handwriting. you have to think careful what you want to write or stick with what you wrote for the sake of authenticity.
> Now young children, by forcing them to handwrite, are denied both these affordances
this sentiment feels very wrong to me for cultural as well as paedagogical reasons.