Do understand that I’m not asking about Elon, I’m asking about the media machine that’s coming after him, and pointing out that any discussion of the rather obvious and concerted effort going after the man gets shouted down by populist opinions and social media haters.
Is there no room to question the machine? Everyone seems to have the same opinions and asking, “hey, anyone else see the concerted effort to destroy this man through the media as evidence of a pretty clear coordinated system?”Just leads to obliteration on social media. It’s crazy hard to discuss the evidence of opinion engineering efforts around unpopular people without people using the opinions generated by that machine to try to silence you from questioning its existence. I mean it’s been a minute since I’ve heard a considered opinion on Elon or Tesla that wasn’t based on an article talking point, and that’s what I’m trying to talk about.
I'm much less concerned about thousands of redditors bagging on Musk than I am about Musk's ability to influence public opinion, which he has extraordinary power to do as someone with a huge megaphone and $200B to splash around.
> JP Doherty did not want to sign the email. But he knew he didn’t have a choice. His son, Rhys, was scheduled to have strabismus surgery in January, correcting an eye issue that made it difficult for him to walk on his own. The procedure cost $10,000 out of pocket. Doherty discussed the decision with his wife, and while she wanted him to be able to quit, they both knew the kids needed his health insurance.
This is one of the employees who signed the "hardcore" ultimatum that Musk set for his employees at Twitter.
The plutocrats who exert outsized control of our lives get outsized attention in the media, as it has always been.
But how would we ever be able to tell if there was a deliberate campaign or not? The man has himself tried to assemble a social media network and his own information machine. Shouldn’t that imply that he is trying to counter another existing system? How would we ever know besides questioning the narrative like I’m trying to do whether we were in a narrative generation system?
I’m aware of the post hoc, ergo propter hoc nature of the question, but as we enter the AI era I see precious little discussion of this stuff and its effects and it’s notable to me that just raising question greets massive downvoted and negative attention on social media platforms.
In real life, in my Asian tech friend circle, no one cares, we just keep driving and buying our Teslas (or Rivians or BMWs). Elon's shenanigans is never a subject that comes up because it has no bearing on our lives. My American friend circle spends time on reddit/twitter and sometimes they have negative opinions but generally don't care much either.
That’s the same for me. My friend groups and I barely talk about the dude.
I keep thinking about Bernay’s statements that you can’t change that people talk but you can influence what they talk about.
It’s weird that nobody I talk to not online reply gives a crap about Elon or his antics except as casual conversation but online it’s like this insane and constant buzz. The contrast is striking.
Even your own comments about him being an ugly commenter on X and putting out an ugly truck are mainstream opinions that have been greatly parroted across media in recent weeks.
I don’t use X and never really liked Twitter so I don’t know what he’s been posting, so apologies for not having a great opinion.
I was trying to ask the question about whether anyone sees the giant propaganda effort or not, not become some Elon defender.
I am asking if anyone is becoming aware of the machine that seems to be shaping public opinion and how difficult it is to even talk about the idea of an opinion shaping machine?
Seems like we should be able to have a civil converation on HN in 2024 about media shaping public opinion and whether it seems like there is a pattern to negative news stories around public figures that are out of fashion without it becoming a “conspiracy conversation” at this point.
I mean all of media seems increasingly coordinated to the halls of power, investigative journalism is almost dead, and billionaires or the large companies they control own almost all media at this point. Does asking whether there appears to be a coordinated system trying to shape public opinion across social media now automatically generate “conspiracy” tags? That seems naive at this point.
I’m concerned because what I’m seeing in my life from people I know personally VS what I see online have diverged greatly. The conversations I have with people who work in technology and are “plugged in” are very similar and seem propelled by the same talking points and opinions, especially when I interact with people who aren’t technologists or more Internet connected. It’s really interesting how profoundly “shaped” a lot of people are in why they think.
But what’s even more interesting is how profoundly hostile people become whenever you ask whether their opinions are being shaped or whether they are seeing that the system is feeding a steady diet of “what to think about who” that seems to be working really profoundly well on public opinions.
It kind of concerns me because the population seems kind of unaware and unprepared for the Internet to become largely machine generated which is inevitable at this point. People aren’t questioning things at all. That’s kinda concerning to me.