Congestion may get worse in some places but the status quo is people commuting from places like Antioch to get to service jobs in Berkeley/Oakland/SF so from a "vehicle miles traveled" perspective it might get better.
In general, rents for the dense housing have declined the most.
This is because the Bay Area is a highly desirable place to live and will continue to get more so as climate change gets worse but the Bay Area stays gorgeous.
Crime is a problem to solve in any Western urban area and is particularly bad here now. Congestion is another problem to solve.
Manhattan has solved both to a degree. I’d imagine we can too.
The thing is, there are plenty of much nicer places even in CA. Just go north a bit, and there's plenty of space to build housing near Napa or Sacramento.
Yet people somehow have to be crammed into the SFBA. Why?
And Napa is dry, rural, and has no employment options.
SFBA OTOH: Temperate, verdant, urban, and swimming in jobs.
I do like Sacramento and Napa. But they are very different lifestyles, despite being so close.
Also, it's very difficult to build in Napa, due to water availability. Sacramento is easier, and it gets even easier as you get farther out...but fewer people want to.
Napa is more green than the SFBA in general. It also is about as hot as most of the Bay Area outside of SF.
> and has no jobs.
Good. Keep asking questions. What caused the lack of jobs?
I didn't say Napa was hot. Sacramento is hot.
But SFBA comprises a large area and large climatic variations. I don't think it's meaningful to consider all 9 (or 13) counties in comparisons, because all things become true. Cold, hot, humid, dry, windy, placid, densely populated, sparsely so.
If you're asking why SF is SF and Sacramento is Sacramento, then I don't think there is a satisfying answer. If you're trying to lead me to a preexisting conclusion, I'd prefer that you just engage directly.
All that matters is proximity to jobs. Sacramento doesn't have a lot of them (although that is changing now), so it's not attracting significantly more population.
Taking it further -- all that matters is proximity to trade routes. SF has (had) a port, and so it grew first. Jobs resulted. The effects were compounded over years.
Sacramento has a river. The river is why Sacramento is not Vacaville. Also, it was selected as the state capital (partially for the available and inexpensive land!), which has greatly accelerated its growth.
Sacramento is the fastest-growing city in CA. It's actually almost as populous as SF, though of course much less dense. And the job market is good, but the jobs are not the same kind as in SF (and fewer are applicable to the typical HN denizen).
I really don't know what you're going for here. Different places are different, for myriad reasons. It's not as one-dimensional as you seem to suggest.
I said a lot about housing, now let's talk about crime. None of the ultra-liberal West Coast cities will be able to solve it within this decade. It'd likely require a Federal-level intervention by the National Guard, ordered by the Emperor Eric Trump (Long May He Rule).
Dealing with drug and gang crimes requires strict law enforcement with zero tolerance for nonsense. And I don't see Democratic governments doing that. They'll just keep ineffectually repeating nonsense about "solving the root causes", "system racism", "affordable housing", and so on.
I'm the bicycle commuter dude who likes walkable and dense cities. Of course course I want just enough of my own private solitude to retreat to as well. But sign me up for density!
Then why do you want density? Do you want other people to live in bunk beds in 40 years?
I really am ok with living with less possible surface area if it means i can have walkable access to all civilization's great ideas and achievements.
that doesn't mean ZERO surface area. and it doesn't mean i would take a mcmansion on 5 acres if i could. Really though, I wouldn't if you gave it to me!
Yes, it is. It's a zero-sum game, and dense cities are more economically advantageous for companies. They allow them to offload their externalities onto their employees, via increased living costs.
Tokyo is a GREAT example. It's now so dense and expensive that some people are forced to live in microapartments, where you can cook your food while sitting on a toilet. And of course, they are priced out of ever dreaming about buying a real apartment.
And the cities nearby keep dying, just a couple of hours away from Tokyo, you can buy a house for basically free.
but also: come on, Japan is the planet's most economically significant TINY ISLAND. you don't have to reach for capitalist conspiracy theories to reason about Japan's issues.
and i say this as a kind of inevitable anti-capitalist!
But if you ask me to live a life of Suburban commuting, I'd tell you, from experience: that's inhumane.
I'm born and raised in Los Angeles. It's not the absolute worst, but it gives me the credibility I need to say yeah i'd rather literally walk and bike everywhere than suffer the inhumanity of car culture.
and that's what i do.
That's why i replied so dramatically. Mostly, it was meant specifically playful for cyberax.
And there's nothing "conspiracy" about what I'm saying. There's no secret global cabal that wants to push people into cities. It's simply caused by a toxic confluence of ideology and economic forces.
Natural resources have nothing to do with it. Extraction industries employ comparatively few people, even in resource-rich countries. If anything, resource-rich countries experience even more densification.
Case in point: Moscow. Its population density is 5200 people per square kilometer. Tokyo is at 6100 people per square kilometer.
The reason is that it's easier for companies to create jobs in cities. It's not impossible for them to do otherwise, but a company with one huge office in the Downtown will likely have a competitive advantage over a company that has multiple distributed offices.
In short, the "abandoned houses" are abandoned BECAUSE they're rural.
I can't understand how this serves your view about dense urban cities being bad.
They are abandoned because there are no jobs around them. And there are no jobs because they have all concentrated into dense city cores.
I would be laughing if it wasn't so utterly sad and depressing that you think that the reality.
Look at changes in rent in Austin vs San Francisco. One builds and the other doesn't.
During the same time, Austin rents skyrocketed: https://www.kut.org/austin/2023-05-09/after-two-years-of-inc...
Again, proving my prediction: more construction equals higher prices.