If a large public sector is a prerequisite for lower-cost transit, then the cost of that large public sector needs to be included in calculating the cost of transit. I suspect that would change the analysis quite a bit.
If a large public sector is a prerequisite for lower-cost transit, then the cost of that large public sector needs to be included in calculating the cost of transit. I suspect that would change the analysis quite a bit.
They do get into these things a little bit later in the interview, but the surprisingly simple conclusion is that when an organization is buying something, the people working out the deal need to understand what it is they're buying, or the organization gets ripped off. It sounds simple to the point of being silly when I put it like that, but it's actually true. And this should feel familiar to a lot of people in tech; how many times have you had to use or implement some very stupid system that got purchased because of buzzwords or because the people deciding what to use aren't the people using the system? (Education is particularly plagued by these problems.) What the Transit Costs Project finds is that this is a thing in public works as well: if your civil service has insufficient in-house technical expertise in its field, or if it doesn't trust its own technical expertise, that tends to make costs go up. It's far from the only contributing factor, but it's an important one.
When cost overruns for these types of projects can routinely be measured in billions of dollars, I think it's not that hard to justify hiring a few dozen civil engineers to keep things under control. The "big" civil service Levy talks about doesn't necessarily need to be big in terms of team size, but it needs to have weight.
$80k per year for for the bus
$50k per driver (https://www.glassdoor.co.uk/Salaries/us-bus-driver-salary-SR...) let's say the bus needs 4 to cover the route 14 hours a day, inc weekends and driver holidays - so $200k
$100k engineer (guessing not needed full time for just one bus?)
$50k cleaner (guessing not needed full time for just one bus?)
Then $570k for fuel and management costs? I've seen figures around $150k per year for fuel.
Some (no doubt out of date) figures: https://www.liveabout.com/bus-cost-to-purchase-and-operate-2...
Just interested where the costs are, I can only assume that the company is making more than $1m a year on the route to take on that expense?
[0]https://careers.sf.gov/role/?id=3743990001605626 [1]https://www.sba.gov/blog/how-much-does-employee-cost-you#:~:....
I’d just note that in the US at least, bus services generally operate at a loss and run many routes due to political reasons rather than efficiency/profitability.
I wasn’t intending to make a statement on whether or not public transit should be independently profitable, just providing context.
I didn’t even touch on ridiculous regulations like “buy America” (aka all buses have to be manufactured in the US) that drive up the cost of transit in a way that private drivers would never accept.
I beg to differ. While profit shouldn’t be the only indicator under consideration, when you are operating a state owned enterprise under a fee for service model, profit is certainly a valid metric to consider.
https://www.dart.org/about/about-dart/key-performance-indica...
>one manager of the local bus company
No offense to said manager, but I’m guessing they aren’t doing the accounting, so it’s not like they are the best source.
Edit: a better source would be the national transit database [0], which tracks the fully audited costs of every transit agency in the US. A very cursory analysis of this file [1], dividing total costs by VOMS (aka vehicles used to provide peak service, not even the size of the whole vehicle fleet) for directly operated bus service (mode=MB, TOS=DO). Gives a cost of roughly $250,000 per year on average across the US. This is fully loaded, including operations, vehicle and facility maintenance, general admin, etc. basically the $1 million per year is little more than a rumor.
[0] https://www.transit.dot.gov/ntd/data-product/2022-annual-dat...
[1] https://data.transportation.gov/api/views/dkxx-zjd6/rows.csv...
Road maintenance is the biggest expense of most local governments in the USA.
Buses obviously take a toll on roads, but the shift to large SUVs is making things worse for the current system of private car ownership.