The only "better" defaults are those that match what people already know, not necessarily because they're objectively better but because most people will already know how to use them. You literally can't get a learning curve better than "you already know it".
Konsole has had tabs at the bottom for about 25 years now (I don't recall KDE 1.x, but they were definitely there in 2.x). Who do you prioritize in a design? Everyone who already uses KDE, and expects them at the bottom, or a subset of users who might switch to KDE and expect them at the top?
More importantly, is the position of tabs -- especially one that you can change! -- like, a real, actual problem?
If you want to grow your user base: The latter.
That is the most frustrating thing about some projects:
They take existing users for granted and make a lot of changes to accommodate the new users they envision coming in torrents.
These users of course never arrive and in the meantime they have alienated the old user base.
With KDE you can put the tabs where you want them.
Or, if you want everything to be like in Gnome or Windows or Mac you can just use these.
The reality is that most users are simply bitterly opposed to change, especially in "subjective" parts of the system like UI design, and it has nothing to do with whether or not the change is actually an improvement that helps people, or can be undone with in 1 minute through a KWin tweak, or whatever. The very example you're theorizing about (accomodating new users who don't yet exist through UI improvements) actually has happened before with positive and negative examples e.g. Blender's complete UI overhaul in 2.8 which was widely praised, versus Gimp which continues to receive flack for its UI choices, versus Gnome which people just endlessly argue over both ways. It is not as simple as "New UI bad, old UI good" no matter how common of a mindset (and how over-represented) that is here.
Developers of the project have to balance these concerns as they see fit, and that is their right. Being an older user of the project (or any user, actually) does not mean every decision and plan in the project is going to revolve around you exclusively, at the end of the day.
That's a weird way to write "and automatically import settings from previous versions to keep the behavior the same without user effort".
But the old users can have it too, that's what configurability is for, just save the state to user config and don't change any such behavior on upgrades, only for fresh installs
The problem with these (and many other UX initiatives) is there isn't a fallback for us who used them from the start.
If there was it wouldn't have been a problem.
Same goes for KDE (if you forget 4), Windows (more or less if you skip Windows 8) since 95, bash, LibreOffice.
Prioritizing the needs of potential new users may bring you actual new users, but not prioritizing those of existing users may send some of them away. How do you know which group is bigger?
Sure, the group of potential users is massive but not all of them will switch. Meanwhile you're making software worse for people who actually use it and, at least for FOSS software, are usually your biggest advocates, part of the developer base, and one of the most important means through which new users are brought in.
The people using Konsole are already the highly technical people, and therefore probably not newbie users.
It would be nice for KDE to have three presets: Windows, Mac, and Classic (= KDE).
Also, if this is the only thing that's annoying, KDE won I guess.
It's cool that KDE lets you do that, but it's a bit annoying actually as it messes with the consistency of KDE. Sure, users can always change their preference to what suits them best, but it would be nice if out of the box all KDEs behaved and looked the same and leave the personalization to the user after installation.
It appears the default is Top in Konsole's source.
I wonder if "new tab" button is always visible now too.
Is it a browser tabs vs. taskbar tabs ideology?
In browsers, that's always at the top. In terminals, depending on if you're a heavy user (and as result, the prompt is at the bottom) or a light user (and the prompt is at the top), you'll likely prefer tabs to be in the same area, too.
I've actually got different settings for taskbar position and terminal tab position between my work ubuntu, personal ubuntu, and personal windows systems.
When I was on Windows, the Start Menu/taskbar was on the bottom, and bottom tabs felt right (as they became available).
Let's all agree that side tabs are of the devil.