Unless you specifically infect a treatment group in an RCT, your 'recently had COVID' and 'no recently documented COVID' groups will vary in ways you're unlikely to be able to fully control-for, no matter how hard you try.
But I agree with your sentiment. The first study doesn't follow people at all, and the second study has a 13-question test. IMO this is very overblown — these studies do not give cause for alarm that would justify shutting down the world again.