The latter is the worse offense because it's much harder to decouple two systems than it is to notice a similarity in two bits of code and to extract the commonality.
This meant that when you wanted to change something on all pages, it was a PITA but not always terrible because tools like grep, sed and awk exist for Windows also.
The nice thing was, you could make a change on any page and know that it would only affect that page and had no (or very little) chance to introduce bugs anywhere else in the system.
I wouldn't recommend the approach, but it wasn't all bad.
If you only need to release it before Christmas no matter what, and sales will wane anyway in 6 months, then even worse crimes against maintainability may find a justification.
The problem is, of course, is that even code that was intended as throwaway tends to live much much longer than expected, if it actually works.
Smetimes you don't want that but sometimes you do, and it's a counter-productive mistake to only ever go one way or the other in all situations instead of identifying what best serves different situations.