I would also like to see a few AGPL cases to demonstrate its validity.
I would also like to see a few AGPL cases to demonstrate its validity.
As an analogy, if I have a plot of land with a sign that says "$1 million to enter", and someone enters without paying, the worst I can do is something like a trespassing charge, not collect $1 million because the sign said so.
In the US, a GPL can be both a license and a contract at the same time [1]. The distribution rights granted by a GPL to the user are conditional on the user's compliance with the GPL.
Contract law allows for punitive damages. Copyright law allows for 1. permanent injunctions against the defendant's continued use and/or distribution of the copyrighted work and 2. statutory damages xor actual damages. Every GPL requires distribution of source code under the same licensing terms to users already given the object code, so the party suing to enforce the GPL can request that the court compel distribution of the source code; the court can agree or disagree. The court can also decide to give the GPL violator the choice of 1. releasing the source code or 2. no longer distributing any copies or derivatives of the GPL'd software until the violator releases the source code or 3. whatever else. The court may impose a punitive fine in any case.
[1] https://sfconservancy.org/news/2022/may/16/vizio-remand-win/
I know, those are all very hard to quantify but still.
As for the AGPL, the AGPL is regarded as the most deadly toxic irradiated poison ever concocted to big tech. You'll be in a very serious meeting with your supervisor, HR, and lawyers if you use AGPL code in big tech. But they'll more likely just outright terminate you. If you maintain a prominent AGPL project, they will not hire you and put you on a blacklist when they find out.
The virality of the AGPL is something no lawyer wants to test in court. They're scared shitless of it.