Sigh, where's the Internet where one can have an honest debate.
No you really don't. If you look at all the bans on "partial birth abortion" they don't allow for any exceptions at all, including to save the life of the mother, even if there's no hope of delivering a living baby. The lack of exceptions that shackle medical professionals in emergency situations are what pro-choice people are against. Pretty much everyone who is pro-choice wants to get abortion done as quickly and as soon as possible. In Washington state, the limits are 10 weeks for prescribing mifepristone, and fetal viability for D&E abortions. Literally nobody is trying to increase the limits beyond viability if there's no risk to the mother. Everyone likes the idea of easy access to mifepristone to get it done earlier.
Go ahead and try to find Democratic politicians that actually want to go beyond that. You can probably find some very hard leftists who will say things like that on twitter, because you can find literally any idiot for any position on twitter. You won't find anyone saying that who actually needs to get elected.
Meanwhile you do see Republican politicians actually banning all kinds of abortion even in cases of rape, when the health and safety of the mother is at risk, and when the fetus will be still or never viable due to medical conditions, which is why people refer to them as "forced birth" positions: https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/texa...
It is really isn't two sides of this debate by politicians that are equally unreasonable. There is opposition to dropping viability (~23 weeks) down to something like 12 weeks because of the proof of the slippery slope where we can literally see by public statements and laws that are passed that Republicans don't respect exceptions for the health and safety of the mother and it is being done obviously in bad faith towards banning all abortion federally.
[ Ed: And that BBC article you cite has a lot of inflammatory quotes from Republicans CLAIMING it was about allowing abortion under all circumstances up until the day of delivery, when the actual quotes from Democrats are about fetal abnormalities and nonviable pregnancies which do not risk the life of the mother -- the mother forced to spend 5 days in the hospital with a child that was always going to be stillborn is a good example of where the Virginia law banned abortion in that case and why Democrats were trying to relax that language. You still can't provide a case of Democrats saying with their own words that they support entirely elective abortions with no medical justification right up until the day of birth. You can only find Republicans saying that they do, which isn't the same thing. ]
Only if you suck down way too much of the conservative news. The right wing media here makes up a lot of this bullshit that has zero basis in reality. Find one elected democratic official at the congressional level that says the day before birth is an acceptable solution.
Meanwhile look at the actual laws conservative states are passing. They are going for a total ban even in the case of rape and horrific birth defects. Don't both sides this. It's not even close.
Is the BBC conservative news and/or right wing media?
> Find one elected democratic official at the congressional level that says the day before birth is an acceptable solution.
Here you go:
>> The Democrat who sponsored the measure said it would allow abortions at any point in pregnancy up until the point of childbirth in certain cases.
From: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-47066307
> Meanwhile look at the actual laws conservative states are passing. They are going for a total ban even in the case of rape and horrific birth defects. Don't both sides this. It's not even close.
This further reinforces my point above about the debate in the US being done at extremities. Alabama (I think) just had their abortion ban so extreme (defining life at conception) that they accidentally outlawed In-vitro Fertilization!
So back to my original point, I'm assuming you are pro-choice from your comment. Where do you draw the line? How many weeks is ok?
>Similar to previous years, in 2021, women in their twenties accounted for more than half of abortions (57.0%). Nearly all abortions in 2021 took place early in gestation: 93.5% of abortions were performed at ≤13 weeks’ gestation; a smaller number of abortions (5.7%) were performed at 14–20 weeks’ gestation, and even fewer (0.9%) were performed at ≥21 weeks’ gestation
For medical conditions that threaten the life of the mother there shouldn't be a limit, the life of the host should never be compromised, though in late stage pregnancy when the fetus would be viable outside the womb care should be taken to take this avenue first.
So this is an example of the individual nuance I mentioned above. But, if we were to have this discussion in a Democratic political setting, many (not all) would agree with us, but there would be quibbling over how we define "threaten the life of the mother" and also what sort of evidence/justification the doctor would need to provide (if any). Also if it hadn't happened yet, at some point here if you identify as a man, your opinion is out.
I think many people on here are misunderstanding that I'm criticizing the left but not the right. I think the right's position of life at conception is much more extreme than the average on the left. But there is definitely extremism on the left, and it tends to be at the party level.
> Under current Virginia law, third-trimester abortions are only permitted if the risk to the mother's life is "substantial and irremediable" - language that Democrats wanted removed.
> The Democratic bill sought to allow for late-term abortions if the mother's physical or mental safety were at risk .
> The procedure would also have required sign-off by only one doctor, rather than the three required under existing law.
This isn't "let anyone have an abortion at any time", like you're implying.
I implied nothing of the sort. I'm disappointed that you inferred that, and that tells me that I could do better in the future (although I'm not entirely sure how, see below), but it's still on you for making assumptions about what you think I believe based on my comment.
If you read my entire comment you'll see stuff like:
> Individual people often have considerable more nuance, but that nuance is not allowed in the political discussions in both major parties.
Please, show me where a major Democratic party discussion has taken place where they drew a line. I've shown you one already.
> On the left, if you try to draw a line at some point, if you are a man, you will be dismissed immediately and told that you have no right to tell women what to do with their bodies. Either gender, you will quickly end up in a position where you are trying to get between a woman and her doctor and trying to have the government make medical decisions. And that's the most charitable take they will have for you. Sometimes it can get much, much worse.
Have you really never seen this?
You're right, you outright stated it, instead of implying it:
> On the other side you argue for no restrictions, typically until the day before birth.
> Please, show me where a major Democratic party discussion has taken place where they drew a line. I've shown you one already.
I'm not sure what this is supposed to mean. You just provided a link to a bbc article where the democrats draw a line.
>> On the other side you argue for no restrictions, typically until the day before birth.
Thank you, fair enough. I didn't intend for the language to be that harsh/hyperbolic, but reading it again as you pointed out it certainly did come out that way. I withdraw the statement.
My anecdotal experience discussing this has mostly been as I said, but that cannot be fairly extrapolated and applied so broadly. (I would still standby that IME there are plenty of extremists on both sides in the US though. Though there's probably some selection bias at play here because the extremists are probably more likely to discuss it in the first place)
>> The Democrat who sponsored the measure said it would allow abortions at any point in pregnancy up until the point of childbirth in certain cases.
The phrase "in certain cases" clearly implies that there are, in fact, restrictions, so you're just wrong to go on the example you've provided. Further, you've said this position is "typical" and yet you only provided one example that doesn't even appear to actually support your claim.
And the example I provided was a proposed law, not just some random internet comment. If it was a proposed law, does it really seem unlikely that people would argue for it and/or believe it? Remember, the original context of this discussion is regarding uniformity of beliefs between people in Europe vs. people in the US
This is putting the scope of options available to emergency medicine doctors under the oversight of emergency medicine, rather than the additional scrutiny and oversight it currently gets as "abortion." This is not abortion as doctors understand it and I don't think as most lay users of the word do either.
As soon as someone brings that up, one can savely ignore the rest of what they have to say on the subject.
Ah yes, the perfect example of our contemporary confirmation bias at work. As soon as someone says something you don't like, dismiss them on that and everything else.
Let's run a test: What's your position on nuclear power vs. solar and wind?
Nuclear has enormous potential IMHO and I think we've missed opportunities by being so afraid it, though the issue of safety and waste disposal are very real. Nuclear could unlock lots of other potential energy technologies though including desalination and other things that take enormous amounts of power, because they burn 24/7 even when demand is low. We cold use that excess instead of wasting it.
Wind largely seems like not worth it, between the disruptions to birds and other wildlife, the huge resources involved to built and maintain it, and the unreliability of it, and general low power output, it doesn't seem to me like the best investment, with maybe a few exceptions like a particularly windy mountain pass or something.
Solar is wonderful, particularly the localization that it enables. The con with solar though is that it requires storage (batteries) because it only produces when the sun is shining. There may be some clever ways to work around that, but Lithium is already becoming harder to get and there are concerns about sustainability even just for building EVs. If we have to start putting huge battery banks in homes, that might not be sustainable/scalable.
How about you? what are your thoughts on those?
My take, in very small nutshell:
- Nuclear is dead, by virtue of beingnto expensive and taking too long to build
- a combination of a more flexible grid, renewables (solar, wind, hydro, geothermal and so on) is the way to go
- EV batteries don't really need lithium, do they?
- solar does not require storage for more than a couple of hours max (!), and the "clever ways" around storage do not require lithium, batteries or storage at all (demand side measures work just fine for yeaes now)
- wind is in some places intentionally held back, even in very suitable places based on BS arguments
- until we stop this pointless discussion aroind nuclear power, wind or no wind and the fact that the sun ain't shining at night, we will not get the necessary transition (which is already happening by the way) up to speed