I hate to tell you, I don't think you can buy a recliner that doesn't look like "old fart stuff". Recliners are kind of "old fart guy chairs".
We found a lazy-boy type glider/recliner... it doesn't look as modern but boy is it so comfortable with a newborn.
(It probably invokes other stereotypes. I don't really know, but either way, you'll be too comfortable to care.)
Feels 60's to me.
ETA: Basically unchanged since 1956 is why!
It's also expensive as all hell. I grabbed a "man-cave" style two seat recliner with middle seat that transforms into a cup holder: that set me back over $4000. Worth it.