IIRC, the main character knew her future daughter would get sick and pass - and the conundrum was, does she tell her husband before the daughter is born (to potentially prevent pregnancy but doesn’t) … which after the daughter was born, the dad/husband learned she knew the future fate - led to their divorce. Was the book different?
So just to spell it out more than the sibling comment - the story doesn't ask "do I decide to have a child, even knowing that they die".
Instead, the focus is on her literally knowing, that morning, that her daughter was heading out to a place where she would die. One word of warning could've prevented the death. Of course, that "isn't possible" from their point of view, but from "our" point of view it seems like it is possible, so she effectively let her daughter die.
Very different emphasis. Both the movie and the Chiang story are great.
I think that's kind of the challenge the story poses. From our point of view, she knows what will happen and "chooses" not to change it, from her/their point of view, it's all already happened, she can't change it.
You're right that she compares it to that, but my reading of it is that that is the whole disconnect/point - she does it view that way, but also doesn't change it in a way that is incomprehensible to the way we view it but that is the only way it could go from their perspective.
I don't think we're disagreeing, just viewing the same actions from a different lens.
Really beautiful and entertaining story, definitely worth the ~hour of reading.
(Also, this isn't much of a spoiler, the daughter's death is mentioned very early in the story's non-linear narrative)
> Similarly, knowledge of the future was incompatible with free will. What made it possible for me to exercise freedom of choice also made it impossible for me to know the future. Conversely, now that I know the future, I would never act contrary to that future, including telling others what I know: those who know the future don’t talk about it. Those who’ve read the Book of Ages never admit to it.
I find the idea of "variational principle" in physics interesting.
https://raley.english.ucsb.edu/wp-content/uploads/Reading/Ch...