It's hard to blame them, though. The author and many others are using the LLM in exactly the way that they're told it should be used. You don't learn that this is wrong unless you're an LLM nerd.
It's hard to blame them, though. The author and many others are using the LLM in exactly the way that they're told it should be used. You don't learn that this is wrong unless you're an LLM nerd.
I have been watching Devin and really see the model they have implemented working well for these kinds of executive function step-by-step LLM tasks. It’s remarkably smart how they implemented it.
https://the-decoder.com/cognition-unveils-ai-powered-softwar...
If you give vague instructions to a junior level human you get poor work product just like AI. But every journalist wants to write that ringer-dinger traffic bringer about ai not being ready for prime time or whatever bad headline works…
Particularly considering that I know multiple people who have made a similar error. The distortion that the extreme hype is generating is pretty widespread.
Hype is precisely what journalists are supposed to cut through. That’s why it’s called ‘reporting.’ So the idea that because many people with no background in AI are confused conflating to reasons why that’s acceptable for journalists writing about it seems rather weak to me.
I do see a broad series of articles that follow the pattern, and do believe it to be clickbait ‘journalism’ of the lowest standard.
Incompetence could be an explanation, but it’s article after article from professional mainstream sources: sources that should know better or at least have a consult with someone who does as part of their due diligence. That implies it’s being done because it gets views, not because it’s good journalism and is therefore intentional. But that is my conjecture you are right.
I don't see why LLM-related topics would be any different. But the reasons why this happens are pretty clear, and poor intentions or even laziness on the part of the reporters are rarely factors.