A super long pipeline allows higher clock rates but it takes a giant dirt nap when branch prediction fails and when you have a cache miss. You end up having massive latencies in these cases.
Further, generally all else being equal a lower clock rate allows you to be more energy efficient.
Agree that it had tons of problems. But branch prediction has gotten better, compilers have gotten better, etc. Maybe they could be handled now!
I’m kidding in these sense that I don’t think a single core could be designed to usefully use 1000W. I get why things happened as they did. But I do still think single threaded performance is much more interesting than multi-core, so I wish we could see how those designs would have evolved.