Hacker News Reader

Comment by Reason077 | Hacker News Reader

When Florida's Sunshine Skyway bridge was partly collapsed by a similar incident in 1980, the replacement bridge was built with a series of "structural dolphins" and concrete barriers to protect against ship strikes. You can see them in the image linked below:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunshine_Skyway_Bridge#/media/...

View on HN

> the replacement bridge was built with a series of "structural dolphins" and concrete barriers to protect against ship strikes.

Given how the Skyway collapse is burned into the local consciousness, I suspect some of the benefit comes from their visibility.

I truly don't know how the dolphins would fair against a massive ship strike but I can imagine them doing their job.

(ship passing): https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FPgQhy2X0AE8yw1.jpg

I would also add those barriers seem to depend on the ship staying intact during collision. Given the immense inertia involved on the bigger ships I could just as easily see a scenario where the barrier ends up ripping through the lower hull while the rest of the ship continues forward.

> easily see a scenario where the barrier ends up ripping through the lower hull while the rest of the ship continues forward

I don’t think that is likely? My intuition is that in order to stay seaworthy ships are constructed with more integrity than that.

I don’t have any hard evidence though, just that I have looked at many ship collision/allision aftermath photos and what you describe is not a failure mode I have seen so far.