There's a lot of trust in Google with that statement. If this changes, how would you know? That's what's Orwellian about it.
It's not hard to imagine the results being silently tweaked by Google - not to say that they will do this, but it's a real danger, because it'd be very bad and hard to detect if they did do this at some point in the future, after we'd all gotten complacent and learned to implicitly trust the results.