Did rms just admit that proprietary software can theoretically have benefits? What's this world coming to lol
Did rms just admit that proprietary software can theoretically have benefits? What's this world coming to lol
I thought the point he made in this article was a balanced one.
http://article.gmane.org/gmane.os.openbsd.misc/134979
As far as the internet, though, as I told a friend long ago - Richard Stallman doesn't need the internet. The internet needs Richard Stallman.
Perhaps he realises that having steam + valve games would be a huge net win for desktop linux use.
Even if you had mainly nonfree software , in theory desktop linux would still be quite a free system in the sense that there would be a level playing field amongst software devs.
Note he actually says "Nonfree games (like other nonfree programs) are unethical". That one believes an act is unethical is different from believing it will have a net negative effect vs not performing the act, and there's often a lot of nuance to be had when something is ethically questionable.
Consider the periodically-raised question of taking control of a botnet in order to shut it down. Opinions on this range from "totally ethical" to "totally unethical", even as much of the "totally unethical" crowd would probably admit that shutting down the botnet is a net good vs not doing so.
Sometimes, "X is unethical" doesn't mean "no good will come of X", it means "we need a third option". RMS believes non-free software is unethical, almost surely believes the existence of software in general is a net good, and that Free Software is the "third option".
I'm sure I've heard Stallman say in the past that software cannot possibly be in any way good unless it is free.
>Nonfree games (like other nonfree programs) are unethical because they deny freedom to their users
I get the feeling he lives in a fantasy world. Unethical is hitting a baby in the face, not allowing people to see how you wrote a computer programme.
As more of our world is software and we rely on it to do things like store our personal information and trust it to respect our privacy etc, how is the availability and ability to understand and inspect that software not a potentially very ethical issue?
Proprietary software isn't a really bad thing, comparing it to say murder or thievery. If you had to choose between doing the wrong thing (which isn't that bad) and not eating, most people would do the wrong thing.
The free or nonfreeness of a particular piece of software is as much of a moral question as the color of sand on a beach.